[quote]Throwing Shield does joke damage in high end PvE and 71 in PvP, compared to its very-similar Strand Hunter melee, here's the difference between the 2: • Threaded Spike does in general more damage across modes • Threaded Spike has more projectile velocity, better tracking between targets better and ricochet properties • Threaded Spike can be catched to refund melee energy Now, Throwing Shield loses to Threaded Spike in all of those departments, it will RARELY hit 2 targets even if they're standing next to each other and will literally NEVER hit 3 in order to gain full overshield My honest feedback to buff it and make it good and fun: • Increase damage in PvE by 20% • Increase damage in PvP to 91 up from 71 • Decrease the number of hits it needs to give full overshield to 2, down from 3 (thus hitting 1 target will now grant half of the entire overshield) • Greatly increase ricochet properties in PvE and slightly in PvP • Getting a kill with the shield should give you full overshield Extra buffs to Offensive Bulwark while we're here lol: • Kills whilst having an Overshield slightly regen melee energy • When under the effects of a melee-generated overshield, or by Ward of Dawn, receive greatly increased weapon handling and reload speed (War Machine, but WILL not work by a Bastion overshield to balance it out in PvP) Thanks and I hope Bungie devs see this as genuine feedback as someone who plays Sentinel like crazy in both aspects of the game; I'm only trying to make a subpar melee better for everyone, whilst avoiding it being oppressive in PvP[/quote] It is weak af.