{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
3/21/2023 5:58:51 AM
7
The point of commendations and guardian ranks, is so players can see what to expect from each other on lfg boards (or atleast this is what bungie mention pre lightfall)
Unfortunately, without negative commendations and the fact that they force players to use them. It makes it a pointless system.
Imagine if we had commendations like poor sport (boots players or quits early), afk, griefer (pushes players off edge, starts encounters early), and angry (yells and blames other). While I'm sure some players would abuse these, for the most part it would give you a heads up, before joining and lfg. Just last week I had someone try to boost me right as the rewards dropped from a legendary campaign mission. Luckily, they were a second too slow.
English
-
Bungies to woke to allow toxic people to be called out in any actual way that helps the player base. Hell im toxic af in these forum and ive had people get in trouble for calling me out, make sense of it.
-
You call yourself "toxic". Are you the kind of person you want to hand out public judgements? Don't you think -blam!- would be trolling any system that allowed negatives? Some people would attach the worst labels to anyone whose play style annoyed them. I know I would be tempted to blast speed runners who drag teammates through content. But lots of people think it's their right to play anyway they want. Considering the lack of respect some players have for another player's gaming experience I can't see things turning out well.
-
Modificato da Asylum: 3/21/2023 3:25:25 PMIm a troll, i troll the internet for fun, thats my kind of toxic. I like to get into peoples heads and see what makes them tick and what makes them cringe. But thats also why there should be solo playlists at base level for people that want to either run through or take it slow. Its about giving OPTIONS so everyone can run as they chose. Im one of those youd report, im not spending 30min in a 10min strike for bounties, not when i know i can do half of them in 1 strike. If bungie would allow me to solo strikes id absolutely LOVE that so i dont have to wait on slower players that are trying to do their bounties for the week at their leisure or ppl that just refuse to learn even the most base mechanics for strikes (sadia elevator anyone? THROW THE FEHKIN BALL!!). But no, im forced into MM with people that are in for vastly different reasons and thus our playstyles clash and everyone suffers for it. Also, you dont make commendations for things like "toxic" or "griefer". Youd them say "speed runner" or "bounty hunter" that way people know "oh ok this persons gonna run through" or "ok this person wants to take their time" and you could then implement a MM system that matches people based off of those commendations so they get matched with like minded individuals, runner with runners bounty ppl with bounty people. For those that are still learning, say new lights; you make a commendation that says "learner" or "newlight" and another for like "sherpa" or "teacher" and you MM 2 learners with a sherpa thats willing to teach them so new players arent immediately put off by ppl like me blazing through or strikes that have mechanics that arent immediately obvious. Not hard to make the commendation system usefull while still giving a heads up about certain player types that people may want to engage/avoid.
-
I'd be [i]tempted[/i] to tag a speedrunner with a negative, but wouldn't do it because everyone really does have the right to choose their playstyle. If someone is running ahead making the easy kills and pulling the rest of the team forward, if they die they might not get a rez. Especially if they've ignored and ran past other's. Some people are team players and some aren't. But almost every one of us needs a team at some point if they want to experience everything the game offers. I'm pretty sure we all want our raid team to respect our experience as a player, so you have to ask yourself where that respect begins. For me it's patrol. I don't poach when someone is obviously chasing kills. I don't melt through PEs when someone is chasing Heroic. I try to not let my desire to be "efficient" effect other people in a negative way. But I play for the fun of playing. I've never seen the game as "work". I know some people feel differently. As for trusting player's judgements to characterize other people's play style? Well... remember those orbs?
-
Technically there are negative commendation, they are part of the report player system. You generally do not want to have negative commendations because people can troll and people with bad behavior can always redeem themselves.
-
Unfortunately the report system doesn't really do anything unless they are actively using cheats in pvp and even then it takes a lot of reports for many people before bungie investigates.
-
Bad behavior can only be changed once called out and acknowledged by the masses. We call them interventions. You dont change bad behavior with a report system that literally does nothing lol they need and deserve to be called out immediately, not weeks or months later after its pretty much pointless to do anything.
