So in his stupid "I'm just gonna stand here and do nothing" punishment rage you think he deserved the chest? Where is the logic in that. For all it was worth the kid might as well have left on his own. You don't do anything you don't deserve anything. So if anything shame on that kid for thinking he was pulling the wool over someone's eyes and hopefully he learns that just cause someone doesn't want to join your clan doesn't mean you have the right to some virtual vow of silence. Be a team player or leave but don't get mad when you're served.