Warlocks have the most melee range though...

So you think damage per swing does not matter

If we are trying to make all the classes the same can I request an ability that one-hit kills for Hunter like handheld supernova or shoulder charge? Since we are making things fair after all. . . I personally can’t wait for those builds that make these abilities constantly accessible in PVP once armor 2.0 comes out. it’s going to be so fun to be killed by these every 2.5 seconds.

Funny, all the down votes coming from titans and hunters 🤣

The uneducated arrogance I’ve seen in these replies makes me sick to the stomach to even think that such a creature can be that moronic. Base melees all have the same range, no ifs, no buts, no whys, no hows, no NOTHING. The only difference is that Warlocks still have their slow melee from D1 carried over for no particular reason and Bungie hasn’t done anything about it. Titans have shoulder charge and synthoseps to make their melees powerful, hunters have liar’s handshake, wombo combo on nightstalker, and top tree arcstrider, the only good melee Warlocks have is on Nova Warp.

Warlocks without range have felt naked since the release of D2. They can either increase speed or range

In destiny 1 it made sense that warlocks had a slower melee because they had the highest range. Here on d2 all classes have the same exact melee range so its stupid if anyone thinks thats balanced.

Warlock: Slow Speed, High Range, Average Damage Titan: Average Speed, Low Range, High Damage Hunter: Fast Speed, Average Range, Low Damage (which doesnt make sense cause its a knife) but it counter balances its speed

Personally I think warlocks should have the greatest range, but the weakest. Titans should have the strongest melee but the shortest range Hunters middle range/damage but fastest melee swing.

I feel as if it's only healthy for all Classes to have the same Melee Range. I looked through this post very lightly, and saw that you mentioned Synthoceps. That, paired with Knockout does lead to absurd ranges. Eleven meters if I remember correctly. But that's pairing two Perks together for Melees. Warlocks do have an Exotic that increases their Melee Range. Ophidian Aspects. The guantlets that make your Handling very quick for all weapons, your Reload very quick for all weapons, and extend your Melee Range. Hunters have a means to extend their Melee Range as well with Way of The Warrior, Top Tree Arcstrider, due to the Perk, Deadly Reach. Every Class has means to extend their Melee by playing on a certain Tree, on a certain Subclass. So you saying "OnLY On SToRmCalLEr" is a blank argument as all Classes require you to invest into a Subclass, and/or an Exotic to get to that point. And that's fair. It's balanced to have all Classes have to make a decision to get those type of lunges for your Melee. As for the speed differences, that's only when your Melee is Charged for certain Subclasses. I understand you thinking that it's slower due to the major difference in animation, but if you put all non-Charged Melees into a recording software, set them side-by-side, frame-by-frame, the weapon you chose to test with will reset at the same time. So again, it's a blank argument.

Nah, why push for all classes to be the same when the point is each one is meant to be different? Each one having benefits and drawbacks. Kinda how RPG's tend to work. If Warlocks have better grenades and hunters have a faster melee what is the problem? Why do you want everything to be the exact same?

Or we can completely diversify the melees Warlocks: longest range, but the least amount of damage Hunter: average range, average damage Titan: lowest range, highest damage

Agreed. We could have some great melee builds if they fixed this. Having a slower melee just makes warlocks terrible compared to D1. Was playing D1 and shotgun meleed. Oh how good it felt to be able to win a melee fight.

No. Warlocks have range Titans should hit harder (but they don't) Hunters have speed. Diversity not conformity