(Edit: If I could redo the poll, I'd separate feeling connected to your Guardian versus feeling connected to the gear your Guardian has acquired. Seems a lot of people have a strong attachment to their weapons and armor while relatively little attachment to their actual Guardians.)
Hello Folks. Here we are, on the verge of Year 3. If you’re a Day 1 player like me, your Guardians have travelled across the solar system, killed Atheon, Crota, and Oryx, killed thousands of other Guardians in the Crucible (and been killed thousands of times), patrolled thousands of miles, tried countless loadouts, started and joined dance parties, rotated the camera countless times just to check yourself out (lookin’ good, Guardian.), kicked a purple ball, and waited for the Warsat on Mars [i]for days[/i].
TL;DR: Are you as emotionally connected to your Guardians as you would have thought at this point in the game? Why or why not?
But, given all that, I don’t feel a particularly strong emotional connection to my Titan (I main a Titan. My Hunter and Warlock exist to collect and hold materials for my Titan. And to get him coffee.). Why is this? After all, I have invested a lot more time in Destiny than in any game I’ve ever played. Yet I feel less connected to my Titan than I did to Edward Kenway (Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag), Axton (Borderlands 2), Booker deWitt (Bioshock Infinite), and Geralt of Rivia (The Witcher 3: The Wild Hunt).
What’s interesting, is that unlike these characters, [u]I am my Titan[/u]. I’m the guy inside the armor. Heck, I even had my wife help me make him so that he actually looks like me. And yet, other than the emotional connection that comes by default with so much playtime on one character, there’s not much else.
I don’t really care whether or not my specific Guardians are carried-forward into Destiny 2. And honestly, that’s kinda sad given the time I’ve invested. (Side note: all I really care about for Destiny 2 is that it’s near-perfect given the historic amount of feedback Bungie has received on Destiny.)
So I’d like to hear from you guys. Are you emotionally connected to your Guardians above and beyond that which comes from simply playing them for days and days? Can you explain why or why not? What would make you feel more connected?
For me, the major components that are lacking are related to the question:[i] Who am I?[/i]
Why was I chosen to be revived by my ghost? Given that I was chosen, I must have been a pretty remarkable person. I’d like to know what I did to be so deserving.
Why in the hell was I living (and dying) in Russia? Was I just trying to escape the planet? Was I a soldier? If I was a soldier there, where did I come from before the war? What, exactly, am I fighting for? To push back the Darkness? Hmm. But why? For the sake of humanity? Seems to me that humanity invited its own destruction. Not super-motivated to fight for it, especially since I can only assume all those who I ever cared for are long gone (Or are they? Destiny 2 plotline, Bungie?).
Bungie, here is where you need to take a page out of Fallout 4. A cut-scene early-on showing my family, friends, community or country suffering, perhaps with a family member imploring me to fight (“Boys! Avenge me! [i]Avenge me![/i]” Red Dawn, anyone?), would have gone a long way in establishing that emotional connection to the game and to my character from the start. As it is, I’ve had to do all of the work to make and keep that connection, and as I said, I feel like any connection there is has more to do with the time spent playing as my Titan, than any truly meaningful connection based on who he is and why he is here.
Not only was there no back-story to establish that connection, but on a day-to-day basis, there is nothing to strengthen my connection to my Titan, other than simply playing more. Sure, I play around with different shaders, and when I find one I really like, it increases my affinity for my Titan. But, we don’t formally name our Guardians. There is no transmogrification. There are no personal spaces – apartments, ships, etc. – that we could make our own; no personal effects from a life long-gone. No flash-backs. No [i]connection[/i]. No [i]depth[/i].
No answers to the question: Who am I?
Perhaps this post is moot. Perhaps Destiny was never supposed to a game that engenders meaningful emotional connections between a player and his or her Guardians. Perhaps instead, the meaningful connections were supposed to be between us and other players. Regardless, I feel like Bungie missed a huge opportunity to connect me to this game. One that I hope is remedied in Destiny 2.
I appreciate any thoughts you want to share. Peace Guardians.
English
#feedback
-
13 RespuestasJust a question for all the players stating that they are not connected to their character in any way, shape or form: How would you feel about starting your character over from scratch in Destiny 2, or alternatively, would you object to starting your character over from scratch in Destiny 2?
-
I'm as connected to my Guardian as are warlock melees connecting to their Crucible target. Funny story for you, they miss half the time.
-
I care about my gear, not my Titan. My Titan is pretty much the same as all other Titans.
-
1 RespuestaYes I am my titan is like my little destiny baby. Would not trade him for gold. Hunter and Warnock I could lose. But not my titan baby not my titan.
-
3 RespuestasIt's not the characters at all that I'm attached to. It's the time I've put in and the gear I've gotten. If my character was deleted but I still had everything I looted, I'd be fine.
-
1 RespuestaIts just a game man, maybe if this character actually talked in game and had a personality (maybe) i would have a connection
-
I don't have an emotional connection with virtual fake characters.
-
1 RespuestaHow do you connect with a character that you barely see, never hear, and has about as much personality as a dead rodent?
-
Editado por SwedishBass: 9/8/2016 1:56:01 PMHonestly? Not as much as I'd expect to, at this point. I still play my warlock a bit more than my other characters, but that's about as far my attachment goes. I've racked up 1200+ hours in this game at this point. Edit: it's probably for story reasons. There simply isn't enough emotional content for me to get invested in my avatar.
-
1 RespuestaThe idea of taking my character through a 10 year campaign has always been the drawcard. I want to take my gear with me too, which in a way defines the character.
-
5 RespuestasMore of a psychological addiction I think ..... Which is probably what they are trying to achieve 😉 Don't forget that WOW was codesigned by psychologists to test if gamers could get addicted to games ........ I'm willing to bet the same team had a hand in destiny at some point ......... Blizzard right ??? 😉😉😉
-
1 RespuestaI have absolutely no connection to my character because I never felt in the story... This isn't Red Dead Redemption or other games where I felt part of the story. My connection to my character is about the same as COD. Just a vessel to get headshots.
-
I'm connected to my guardian in that it is my avatar in the world of Destiny and I care what I do. I still don't know why I did what I did through the whole game it was fun, but mostly just stuck it out to get all of my year 1 raid gear and all the neat exotics... Then came year 2 and someone at Bungie said thanks for playing, now throw all that gear away! I kept all of it... Finally, the big bad shows up, Oryx, and I think, "hey, finally an evil nemesis and I've got a good backstory built up!" (Even though all my guns at that time were kinda worthless.) So, killed Oryx, killed him again, got the harrowed raid gear and firefly Smite of Merain, and now... I feel like my warlock deserves 20 years of R and R like the guardian who locked himself in the top of a colony ship in that one level in Ol' Russia. So, going forward, I don't really know what to think. Become legend? I did that, I think? Now I have to become an Iron Lord? Okay... Not to be a jerk, but I feel like I should have a statue, be part of the Vanguard, and be an honorary Iron Lord at the least, but I digress... I got this game to be involved in a Bungie game with a story, in a huge open world, with cool enemies and weapons, but I feel I've been lied to over and over. The main thing I can say is only Bungie could have managed to string me along for so long while lying the entire time; congratulations Bungie! Yes, I like my guardian a lot and feel a good connection with him, but I feel like I keep buying dinner and Bungie continues to take advantage of me! So, please Bungie get your crap together! Do you even know what game you're making? Okay, so yes guardian good; rant over!
-
1 RespuestaI care about my loot, my loot that I earned and I use it what represents me as a player idc about my character just keep my loot
-
1 RespuestaMy hunter is my main, hell its me in a weird way its a reprensentation of my personality (loadouts, armor, subclass and shader) my guardian is a way to express my personality throught a fictionsl world. [spoiler]I'm weird i know[/spoiler]
-
1 RespuestaI mean ive made little back stories for my characters, but nothing to in depth. Thats about as far as ive connected to my characters.
-
1 RespuestaI have no attachment to the character whatsoever. However a class? That's a different story altogether.
-
Let's just pray that bungie doesn't delete all our gear in Destiny 2.
-
1 RespuestaI'm emotionally connected to my K/D ratio.
-
1 RespuestaI've deleted 8 characters so its a good thing i wasn't attached to them
-
24 RespuestasAnyone who is emotionally connected to a video game character needs psychotherapy and should not be allowed to operate anything bigger than a toaster
-
1 RespuestaThere was a time where I identified with my character ... Then Bungie nerfed my feelings :/
-
1 Respuestalike with mass effect i want my character to be importable to destiny 2 with all my skills and hopefully gear intact but unlike mass effect i'm not attached to my character i'm attached to the effort i put into levelling it up and getting the gear with the exception of my hunter who was made as a female by my stepsister and now im attached to my hunter being female although i wish i could change the face because apparently my stepsister wanted the hunter to be ugly as shit
-
1 RespuestaSadly this game is mostly about loot and playing with your friends so I'm not very hopeful going forward about story. It's simply a thin narrative to justify hopping around the solar system. Doubtful they'll ever expand on it in any meaningful way. I agree with you wholeheartedly and have been looking for a way to express what i was thinking. You have worded it perfectly.
-
7 RespuestasI do NOT want to lose my guardians in Destiny 2... I worked so hard on my faction level, gear, etc. The only thing I would like to change is my face... that's it. I do NOT want to start over... please Bungie. Please don't make me start over...
-
7 RespuestasEditado por Redeemer: 9/7/2016 1:25:31 AMOddly..I felt more of a connection with Master Chief, he also rarely spoke, but [i]WE[/i] were the Spartans under that armor from CE to Reach...don't get me wrong I liked this game, but never got as [i][b]in[/b][/i] to the character as I did in [i] Bungie's [/i] Halo series...but, that's just me