It had a pretty bad storyline Guilds were meh Dlc was good but it was dlc Perks and levelling was pretty poor for an rpg Races didn't do anything apart from make your character look different and give you a perk you would hardly use Combat was meh Bugs were everywhere Shouts were stupid (at endgame they were fun but during the most of the game they just tried to make puzzles harder) Ai was pretty bad for the time, I get that ai for open world games can be crap but at least they don't spend half the time walking into a wall Map was good, had nice scenery but general layout especially with paths were set out pretty poorly, Its annoying having to circle a mountain before getting up it. Mods and community were definitely very good While the hud was nice it didn't fit in the game well. No elven ruins everywhere :( In general I give it a 5.5/10 not amazing but still a bit above average