I think every one just is attempting to pretty much draw comparisons to something that is almost completely different. It's just like what happened when Bungie went from Myth, Marathon, Oni, and so many other games to Halo. No one thought they would make a good game when they switched gears. Once the beta is shown, maybe we won't have to hear all the BS once they figure out that this is different. I'm excited for it nonetheless, and I hope Bungie delivers.