You're missing the point. It's the same concept. They're both Year 1 weapons and both vastly overpowered so when The Taken King came out they decided to leave them behind [b]for now [/b]. So comparing any year 1 weapon to a year to is useless. Unless you're taking into account them both in their prime and still, Gjallarhorn still wins. Even a close second would be Truth just for the sheer ruthless tracking and that's a year two item now.