Lucky you, I have been hoping for a scout with firefly to drop for me, and you got two! I would be happy with either one, but would probably concentrate on the Badger. While I prefer scouts with mid impact/mid rate of fire, like the Rapier, the mag size on the Rapier, if I recall correctly, is 13, while the Badger is 14. So, with the higher impact, the Badger will do considerably more damage per magazine. Firefly is amazing, I still use a 300 damage Calling, even though I have a maxed out Another NITC. The Calling may have lower damage, but it frequently kills 2 or even 3 adds with a single headshot (plus it has field scout, 27 round mag.) And headshots can clear out a gang of thralls right quick.

Both are good because they have Firefly, which is very good for taking out mobs. Rodeo is not super useful, since recoil on Rapier is not that high. Still could be useful though as it will probably make the gun rock-solid stable. So your roll is good but not as good as the vendor version, which has Outlaw (fast reload after crit kill). Hammer Forged is nice - not required, but puts your range to max. Main issue with this gun is that it has a small mag and no perks to help mitigate (Field Scout, reload perks). Who's Next is okay, a more limited version of Outlaw since you have to kill with the last few rounds of the magazine to make it work. Badger high-caliber rounds are nice for stagger. This is a better roll than the vendor version, which has bad perks. I would start with Badger as it's a solid, hard-hitting weapon and will likely serve you well. But both sound decent.

Bump