I feel you on the crying issue. I wish people would discuss things more than just doing what the guy did who originally posted this thread. I have to disagree with you though on people knocking the class when they haven't played it. I mean, I did say I don't like knocking things I haven't tried but at the same time it is still possible to critique it. From a personal standpoint I just like to go more in depth and hands on. The current state of the game affects things like this as well. i mean people are all running around with short ranged guns in the current meta and I think that's where the shoulder charge excels. All in all I believe it should just put you on one shot instead of the one hit kill. I just hate 1 shot kills in pvp