I was one of the best quake 2 players in the world and I'll tell you right here that you can't just say "skill". Type Rocket Arena in google if you want to see me. You have players in quake who are railers like me, which is similar to sniping, mostly revolving around twitch play and good map awareness. You have chainers which would be similar to AR or LMG which revolves around maintaining a steady hand on your mouse and extreme map awareness since you are engaging close and must deal with splash and spam. You have rocket users who rocket jump off of walls to move in aggressively and flank which revolves around twitch gameplay and extreme map awareness. This I would say is similar to shotgun users. What it comes down to is if you are valuing thumb skill over map awareness and strategy. I voted for results cause frankly I didn't care how my teammates played in clan matches, I cared about winning. But destiny I would want to have the best shotgunner, best sniper, best primary, best aggressor, best at leading a team, etc etc.