Here's my opinion; Gameplay; Bioshock 2 wins by far. There's still hacking, Power to the People stations, research bonuses, Little Sister harvesting, your melee is its own weapon, you're in Rapture, and finally; you can dual wield Plasmids and Weapons. (the only thing Infinite had over 1) The original comes in second, Burial at Sea Ep. 2 in third And Infinte/BaS Ep 1 last. (felt like a generic shooter) Story; Bioshock 1 all the way! [spoiler]Would you kindly?[/spoiler] Bioshock Infinite/BaS 1 & 2 come second. [spoiler]Li'l Elizabeth's head getting caught in the portal in BaS. T-T[/spoiler] Then 2 in last. (haven't played Minerva's Den yet) It was a great story, just not as good as the other 2. In general; 2 1 BaS 2 Infinite BaS 1