{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
1/6/2022 11:38:11 PM
13
Petra killed Uldren, right?
I was replaying Forsaken on my Hunter to get it done before Witch Queen, and noticed that when Petra gives us her sidearm she says ‘it’s the weapon that…’
To me that says she pulled the trigger on Uldren
Is there any evidence that we as the Guardian killed Uldren? Just curious
-
It’s left purposefully vague. Hell even both gun sounds play simultaneously during the black screen. By never confirming it Bungie allow you to believe what you want, while also not absolving you of guilt. Even if you want to think Petra pulled the trigger and your Guardian didn’t, you still stood by and watched as a defenseless and broken man was executed in front of you.
-
I always found it strange that we had to repair the ace before we could use it, but we were supposed to have shot uldren with it.
-
2 RepliesNo, you did
-
Edited by Ahmed_Al-Muhairi: 1/8/2022 7:09:18 PMWhen I played through Forsaken, it was glaringly obvious that the Guardian pulled the trigger. It was very poetic, as both Cayde's and Uldren's death scenes were mirror images of one another. The Ace of Spades HAD to kill Uldren. I think this community often fails to realize that Bungie is limited in what they can show in a Teen rated game. I'd wager that an execution style murder of a human/humanoid (this matters, as shooting an alien or monster isn't equivalent when it comes to Maturity rating) character with a firearm would be firmly in the "M" rating category, and every way that Bungie could've depicted it visually (with a "T" rating) would've had to be so drastically toned down as to have no effect. Thus, the artistic choice to let the screen fade to black (imo this decision was cinematically far superior to seeing the shot fired) during both of their death scenes. I could be wrong about this, but this is how I've always thought about it.
-
I think it’s up to your interpretation. I believe we both shot him.
-
We both killed Uldren. It isn't one or the other.
-
It's been investigated and Sounds of Ace and VD are both Present. Both the Guardian and Petra Shot Uldren.
-
-- GDPR: removed by user request --
-
It's your personal choice. If you didn't then you didn't. I killed him. And I'll kill him when I see Uldren Sov come back out. I have zero doubt he is manipulated by savathun now.
-
1 ReplyEdited by boi: 1/7/2022 12:37:36 AMNo evidence. The final cutscene shows the guardian pulling the trigger, that’s all the proof we need
-
Vague. In Season Of The Lost, When Crow decides to leave, his dialogue could imply that we pulled the trigger.
-
It's been implied that both you and Petra pulled the trigger , notice how Crow says "And You!!!!!" After Savvy showed him his past I killed Uldren,and I would kill him again ,and again and again
-
I killed that scum, petra just wants the credit.
