The controller is the most confortable option to play a shooter for many players. Our interface with the game becomes much more streamlined making it very hard to press the wrong button or scrolling the wrong way (yes, I am looking at you "heavy weapon" that keeps getting selected without ammo when I switch weapons). But I agree, it also is somewhat the inferior input device: it simply isn't as easily accurate as the mouse to aim and so it needs a little push. However I also agree. Bungie needs to tune it so that it evens the playing field for all players. Getting rid of it is not the best option.