I'll be the first to admit that I suck with photoshop, but the design is very similar to other works in which existing assets/pictures are put together on a plain background. I am however an art student, and I can say from that perspective something about the cover seems rather off - the Traveler in particular. Something about the box doesn't seem professional when compared to the previous one. Nothing flows. Also, the game title is slightly difficult to read as a consequence of being slapped over a character. Don't use the "could you do better?" response; it just comes off as fanboyish. Unlike those at Bungie, I'm not a professional artist, and designing the cover is not my job.