It's taken me a little longer to post this than I'd hoped, but it obviously was a crazy week for me and I did not get back home until late yesterday evening and was pretty jet lagged today. There is a lot of speculation and discussion about the Destiny Community Summit and I know my fellow attendees have been posting their thoughts, so here are my impressions of the event.
To begin I want to say that I understand how incredibly fortunate I was to be invited to be a part of this. I know all the speculations going in about motivations by who was on the list and even within the group of attendees there was a wide range of opinions on what the event would be. I believed the first and foremost reason for the summit and most important goal would be to try to rebuild and repair the relationship between the community and developers, beyond that we had a lot of discussions before hand of what the community would like addressed/discussed. To that end I wrote up a summary of those discussions to take with me as things I hoped we could cover.
As this will go well beyond the forum word limit, I’m going to link the sections below.
[url=https://www.bungie.net/en/Forums/Post/244629481?sort=0&page=0&path=1]Thoughts and hopes going in[/url]
[url=https://www.bungie.net/en/Forums/Post/244629507?sort=0&page=0&path=1]Day 1 experience[/url]
[url=https://www.bungie.net/en/Forums/Post/244629542?sort=0&page=0&path=1]Day 2 experience[/url]
My fellow attendees have written and talked about what their experiences were and I know there is still skepticism in the community as to motivations and intent on all sides, but this event was literally everything I hoped it might be and then somehow proceeded to exceed that exponentially. I’m as hopeful for the future of a Bungie game as I’ve ever been.
Thank you.
Edit: I want to add something else to this as I've been seeing and reading takes on the summit and I want as honest a narrative as possible.
I don't agree with any notion that this is the first time Bungie has listened and that their listening to us at the summit is going to potentially "save the game".
I feel that discounts things we were shown already being developed as well as not only easily identifiable player impact throughout D1, but everything that we've seen in developer comments, TWaBs, updates and roadmaps since launch.
I know we did have very direct impact on some things and were very helpful in thoughts and opinions on a lot of things going forward at the summit, but I don't want to take anything away from the impact of your feedback and the things we already saw them doing and/or know are coming/in development that are directly from them listening to the community at large.
What I saw was a company that has heard your voices and feedback on the game and this summit was another step in that process and a chance for more intimate face-to-face discussions on those thoughts and ideas.
Thank you again.
[spoiler]The measure of this moment is the measure of the hope it can bring and if it's gonna make a difference, the difference will be easy to see.
-Swell[/spoiler]
-
1 ReplyGood read. Glad to hear the experience was such a positive one. Hope to hear a podcast discussion on it later!
-
Man after going through all these back and forward discussions. This is by far the best raid EVER. except for VOG
-
For one everyone had to sign a NDA. Meaning you can't even say much. You literally told everyone how great the D2 pre-beta was (and look how that turned out after bashing people for criticizing Bungie), your post has zero credibility, dude. If that event was everything YOU hoped for I highly doubt anything good, let alone a "new game mode" will come out of it. The new game mode is probably some ripoff of something else. Why you were even invited is beyond me, you've only represented the voices of the community that share your ideas and thoughts (and that's not a lot).
-
Stop talking your mouth full please sols
-
Edited by N3wter: 4/23/2018 2:46:26 PMThe only problem with the summit is the NDA. If Bungie wants to bring players back they need to lift the curtain now not 5 months from now. We all know nothing is fixed in the May update. So there will be no hype for it. What should be happening is showing the changes. They should have made videos of the summit and released them each day.
-
Edited by FreakinMitchell: 4/23/2018 8:33:29 PMIt's telling that Bungie is holding back all the changes to weapon slots and perk randomization to September. It's almost like Bungie wants to make their player base give them more money in order to enjoy the updates we asked for in a full game.
-
1 ReplyMtashed's facial expressions in his video told me enough. September is not going to put D2 where D1 was at. Mtashed even said it. Words of advice. Just wait for the third or fourth game.
-
This is really simple . I'm paid up to September. If the September "dlc" has nothing I enjoy then its over for myself and I'm ok with that I'm just one gamer Bungie wants to go down a certain road and I don't want to . They can hype all they want . D2 broke me of pre-ordering anything Bungie . It's really simple show everything you got before September release to try to win folks back...
-
I hope you're right. Time will tell. My personal belief is that the best feedback comes from the unhappiest customer. Sadly too many of the people that were invited appear to be those that would have been easiest to please.
-
No one cares
-
1 ReplyHahahahaha what a sucker
-
...blagged.
-
😂 Your post is at zero 😂
-
60 RepliesI give you a credit for disclosing your intended topics of conversation and the detailed resume of your time at the Summit. From what I have seen or heard other participants say you are more open about the logistics than anyone else. It was interesting to get an insight into how the Summit actually worked. I understand that all of you are under NDAs and are unable to discuss details of what Bungie is working on and therein lies my big problem with all of this. I, and everyone who bought D2, are the paying customers. We are the ones who got a product which, based on previous experience, fell short in both content and expectations. (Obviously some people like D2 so everything I say is a generalisation). The community, have been posting feedback, of all types, for years with little acknowledgement or response from Bungie. Now if, as was the stated purpose of this Summit, to get attendees to approve or disavow what Bungie have been working on that’s fine. I get that Bungie have taken action on community feedback to ostensibly improve the game and picked XYZ person to comment on their work. I also get that not everyone can ever possibly be happy with everything that Bungie come up with. Personally I saw you mention the name ME Cheong and groaned with despair at what further convoluted Guided Games systems Bungie may have come up with. ( Sorry my hobbyhorse). For Bungie to get it’s paying customers back on side it needs not only to give a few selected people it’s reasons for doing what it did to D 2 it needs to tell us all. It needs to tell us what they are doing to turn things around and not shroud their work in secrecy. ‘Nudge, nudge, wink, wink, it will all be great, take my word for it’ from You Tubers and Streamers whose opinions I do not value will not work. Without thousands of ‘me’ buying future DLCs the Destiny franchise will fail. It is the ‘me’ that Bungie needs to convince to trust them. Unless Bungie open up to us all people will continue to think that this is a marketing excercise to build hype. I understand that you can’t comment on specifics and would not ask you to. I also understand that you have no say in how Bungie behaves towards its community. I leave my comments here in the vain hope the someone from Bungie may think upon them
-
Hey mate. Just a question that's way off topic here lol, but at this Summit, did anybody at all at anytime during any of your chats ask why a well known cheater that goes by the initials C_I_C hasn't been banned yet? There are multiple videos of this guy and 1 of his buddies cheating their way through Trials since D1 and they are still doing it to this day. Obviously they would have been reported hundreds of times by now and yet they are allowed to continue. I'm no PvP player and haven't run into the dude myself, but I just find it unbelievable that someone so notorious and well known amongst the PvP player base hasn't been banned yet, and I thought maybe one of the PvP reps at the Summit may have brought it up. Glad you had a good time there though dude ☺
-
4 RepliesKnow what would of been really great? If you made this a video talking about your thoughts rather then making me go through posts. ;)
-
27 RepliesEdited by Lost Sols: 4/23/2018 4:25:55 PMThe second day was spent once more in our discussion groups and saw us playing unreleased content and giving more opinions on it. We had two main sessions. One of the groups with the content team and one with the sandbox team, then we switched again. During that break for lunch, I got to talk to Peter Sarrett again along with Justin Truman, both of whom were as gracious and open as they could be on my thoughts and questions. Then Coz came and found me and asked me if I wanted to meet M.E. Chung. She was one of the other people I was really hoping to get to talk to about the social features within the game, my experiences with Guided Games and my hopes and ideas of what could be going forward. Coz led me over and she was in a conversation, so I was able to actually talk to Pete Parsons again for a few minutes and just give him my thoughts on the event so far. Then I got to spend about 20 minutes talking to M.E. and Steve D, Bungie’s social design lead. I got to give them my thoughts on what I feel has worked with GG and what hasn’t and we discussed games that have had similar systems and why those worked as well as ideas they have for improving functions within D2’s social systems. I walked away from the conversation feeling like it is something they very much are committed to improving. [url=https://amp.reddit.com/r/DestinyTheGame/comments/8ebdit/lore_summit_meeting_with_christopher_barrett_and/?__twitter_impression=true]During this time Myelingames, Aeroknight and Mercules were able to sit down with Chris Barrett to really give feedback and thoughts on the story and lore.[/url] I was disappointed I missed out on that discussion as it was another I really wanted to participate in, but the story and lore feedback was in very good hands with that group and I ended up participating in another sandbox discussion going deeper into things we’d talked about the day before. We ended the day with about 2 hours of everyone back I one big group to ask about anything that we felt hadn’t been discussed enough or hadn’t been brought up but needed to be. I would again say that literally every major suggestion or complaint was heard throughout the summit and I think the duration was perfect as the final hour was really about more QoL changes as all the heavy topics were over. DeeJ then proceeded to end the day perfectly when it was suggested there be a discord chat to keep the conversation going by saying that he felt that would be too much like a player council and that wasn’t what this was about and that they didn’t want to create a situation where it feels one group of the player base gets to head up feedback. The devs were really happy with what they felt had been accomplished and they’d gotten out of our feedback and loved how it turned out. Hopefully this is something they do again in the future and hopefully next time it is all new faces and voices in the room to get that experience and to get to be heard from their perspectives. The event ended and everyone made their ways back home. Some were leaving for their flights over the course of the final hours of the Summit and some like myself stayed in town a little longer for various reasons. I was able to meet up with one of my friends and fireteam members,Tim of Tacoma as well as a couple of friends from the studio for dinner and then headed home Saturday afternoon. It was an incredible experience and one I am extremely grateful to have been a part of. It was also really incredible to get to know some of this community like Aeroknight, Cammycakes, Lulusoccer, Myelingames, Pope, Hovey, Swainstache along with so many more that I got to talk to about Destiny, the event and other things. They were again all really cool and very much gave all the information they could to try to make this game and universe the best it can be.
-
1 ReplyGood stuff. Thanks for the feedback. Sounds like the future is hopefully going to right some wrongs.
-
1 Reply‘Twas a good read. I appreciate you taking the time to make this post
-
4 RepliesWhy was summit needed? Bungie had the beginnings of an epic Destiny at the end of D1 based on user feedback for three years. Then Bungie just scrapped all the years of user feedback and started from scratch with a failed end result. Just give us D1 sand box with new strikes and adventures and cool bad guys and awesome new gear. Seems so obvious.
-
4 RepliesI don't know, that NDA has me [i] extremely[/i] skeptical about anything. This is also on top of the fact that Bungie seems to be pushing a "wait until September" stance with a lot of stuff. I'm honestly going to push a "wait and see" approach because of the NDA.
-
Yeah -blam!- all that. Ill wait and see. I have been taken on this ride before and not falling for it again. Dlc coming so lets hype up the hype train with a bunch of nda's and nothing but the word of streamers and youtubers who i personaly feel have a huge responsibility for the state of the game. Youtubers promoted D2 on the 1st invite to the studio and as soon as the betas came along we all started to notice the things wrong with the game. Mean while youtubers were like"its amazing, its this and that". NO not this time. Not personaly saying you lost but people and channels like TV and PD, houndish, that idiot mesa have all contributed to the shit state of the game by supporting and jumping in the train early on when most of us felt something was wat off about the game.
-
3 RepliesUpvoted.
-
Lol, they needed a summit to bring back all the common sense and QOL improvements they should never had taken out
-
Sometime, I like MOBA communities more than these people
-
I'm glad it's going to turn out good.