{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
Edited by AidanPryde:
8/29/2017 6:39:17 PM
44
Error Code Spinach
Got Error Code Spinach after some lag. Ikora wasnt there after the door opened, the door behind it was open no more enemies. Seems the script broke.
Edit: Scan&Repair didn't work. Reinstall didn't work. Making it a completely trusted program in Kaspersky Internet Security 2017 didn't work.
Edit 2: Will try a VPN when i get home from work. Will update if it works or not.
Edit 3: During Lunch i tried to forward Ports, didn't work either.
Edit 4: I tested it now and i can confirm it is some form of a network related isse. Which exactly i can not say.
Steps:
I installed Avira Phantom VPN, the Test Version and started it.
I chose England as safe location because of the Ping times from Ireland
Started the Battle.net App.
Started the game, chose my Hunter and played through the Mission without any Problem, first part and second part on the command ship. I also skipped all Cut Scenes.
Then i closed the game
Closed Battle.net
Turned off Avira Phantom VPN
Restarted Battle.net
Started the game
Created a new Hunter
Played till after the Plaza, got the Part to go after the Speaker and Bang, no Ikora, no more NPC's and after a short while Spinach Error. And I also skipped the first Cutscene.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ISP is Magnet Entertainment Ireland
Router is a Technicolor TG589vn v3
Product Name: TG589vn v3
Serial Number: XXXXXXXX (edited out)
Software Release: 10.5.2.O
Software Variant: CN
Boot Loader Version: 2.0.8
Product Code: XXXXXXXXX (edited out)
Board Name: VDNT-1
UPNP is enabled. Ports from here: https://www.bungie.net/en/Help/Troubleshoot?oid=13610 are open and UDP 3074 is forwarded
English
#Help
-
1 ReplyDone it 5 times now, still Spinach error.
-
2 RepliesIt's a network/router error. Basically it looks like Bungie are using some form of peer-to-peer (P2P) networking, which requires your router to have uPnP enabled (which allows automatic port forwarding) or you have to forward the ports manually in your router NAT (network address table). I have uPnP enabled, but I get the same error (spinach) at the same point. You can either: 1. Set up port forwarding as explained here ( [url]https://www.bungie.net/en/Help/Troubleshoot?oid=13610[/url]). 2. Use another network that doesn't have port restrictions on by default, such as: - You phone data network (using your mobile hotspot function) - Using a proxy/VPN service (like Hola, NordVPN etc) Bungie have really dropped the ball with this. They should take a lesson from the team who make Warframe if they want to see how good P2P game code is done!
-
1 ReplyHello all, Thank you for the detail reports on your network setups and the troubleshooting steps you have attempted! I will be passing along data from this thread to the rest of the team for further investigation.
-
I think i found a solution n.n' [quote]Basically disable all the firewalls, Windows and modem, seems like it's absolutely necessary disable both, just access to the modem control panel to disable. Better than nothing.[/quote]
-
1 ReplyEdited by Varkolaak: 8/29/2017 9:00:46 PMAlso with Magnet - both the TG589 and TG789 Thomson/Technicolour (same company) routers have this problem with Bungie's P2P netcode. Had the problem in PS4 console beta, and now in PC beta These routers are used by loads of ISP's around the world as they can be locked down and configured with custom firmware by the ISP - somewhat of a rarity for VDSL modem/routers. Neighbor using a Huawei F2000 modem/router has no such issues. UPnP is enabled. Port forwards have no effect - and given that 3 of us will be playing, are not a viable solution Mobile tethering / VPN fixes it, however is not a viable solution No change with latest patch.
-
3 RepliesAnyone tried it with the patch they just dropped? Is it working now?
-
This is the same error that happened in PS4(i think it happened as well in Xbox) but with a differente name,it was called "Moose". Hope Bungie fix this by launch date on console and then on PC,otherwise will lose some userbase,if they care with that.
-
Edited by Nerusonu: 8/28/2017 8:51:10 PMIt's the same error that happened on the console beta, but there it had the name "Moose"... It's some sort of incompatible router--game connection. In the console beta it happened more with Thompson/technicolor modems/router Hope they fix this or I'm not buying the game... Had to use mobile hot-spot to pass that part.
-
Same problem. Spinach error occurs after a few seconds after the (eventual) opening of the door in Tower North.
-
Been getting spinach error for an hour now, Hope it gets fixed asap
-
8 RepliesUsing a VPN fixed it for me. After i did the first mission i switched back and sofar i did the strike and it worked!
-
Using a vpn fixed it for me
-
Same here.... Error Spinach :(
-
i got the same error, after i defended the plaza i try to move forward, door wouldn't even open at first, have to head back to the plaza and wait a little and go back the door will open. two times now during walking to the next place to be the spinach error would occur. trying to get back into the game afterwards would not work, i have to restart the game every time, third time i got to an empty place where according to a friend should be a battle taking place but no one is there for me. took a little time there then the error got back. fourth time i tried exact same thing happened.
-
1 ReplyYeah same thing happend to me
-
Same here like 4 times in a row. Restarted the game and internet and everything doesnt work
-
The exact same thing happened to me too. Thinking of not buying this game now after this crap...
-
I think it's useless if i mention that i got that issue too. (occurs when i have to locate the speaker)
-
Any of you running Windows Insider? Could that be a cause? (Different Drivers, etc.)
-
yah me 2 if anyone know how 2 fix this please help i was wating for this shit all day comon
-
Same 8 Times on 2 Char. 7 times before the cutscene 1 after. Wi-Fi X Box One -> Wired PC = Same Fight
-
Edited by d3fin3d: 8/28/2017 6:54:41 PMSame error for me. Finished the 3-wave courtyard part, but every time I run through the doors to enter the sort of city area (when they eventually open! took a few attempts here!), the whole place is empty and eventually I'm met with the spinach error. Tried 5 times now on both EU and NA servers. http://i.imgur.com/71x5cMC.png
-
same here....5th times i try
-
same here.. i finished the part after zavala and got into the ship but then i got the error..
-
1 ReplySame here, creating another character does not help either.
