[b] [/b]

Okay first off I would like everyone to know that, as soon as Yor gave up his Light, he was no longer a Guardian or of any Class Also, Rose and Thorn were always the same, there was no transformation. The hand cannon was built on the Moon with tainted material and when it was brought back as a trophy it was called Rose because it represented something beautiful, but as the infection took hold, Yor realized that the weapon only had the thorns and pain of a rose and changed the name Evidence for Hunter: Hunters are known for striking out into the wild and universe where no one else has been before (and also for taking dares and bets), so it's perfectly logical that a Hunter would journey to the Moon. However, there is no evidence at all aside from that showing that he was ever a Hunter: no knife and a supposedly stolen cloak. Also, to whom it may concern, HAVING A HAND CANNON DOES NOT MAKE YOU A HUNTER. Far too many people have said that Yor was a Hunter just because of his weapon, and that is a horribly wrong assumption Evidence for Warlock: a Warlock could be driven by a thirst for knowledge to go to the Moon. That's it. Also, the grimoire image of a Warlock means nothing; both the picture for TLW and Thorn are focused on the gun (the image clearly has a ring around the weapon, they just needed any random person to hold the weapon) and wielded by some Bungie employee's Destiny character Evidence for Titan: Rezyl Azzir went to the Moon to see if the gruesome stories were true and, if so, what damage a Light could do if it faced them. It is perfectly acceptable that a Titan would venture out to find out what enemies await us. Rezyl Azzir also met Xyor the Unwed as Yor did and went to see if the stories were true as Yor said he did. Rezyl was a beacon of hope to humanity as Yor said he used to be, and Xyor's curse on Rezyl showed that she knew he would survive. Also, Rezyl was the first person to go to the Moon after the Collapse, just like Yor is said to be the only person to hav gone to the Moon since the Collapse Since Yor had no Class, it makes perfect sense that the Rose of Dredgen Yor will go to the Class responsible for his downfall. Also, anyone can wear a cloak, so Yor could hav been any Class, and if his cloak still remains them of course it will be worn by Hunters. I mean seriously, it's a game mechanic; just because Bungie has only allowed our characters to wear cloaks if they're Hunters doesn't mean that other people can't wear cloaks. In real life, if you tried putting on a cloak would there be an invisible force to stop you?

This doesn't belong in lore. You don't belong in society. Quit using up the oxygen that smarter people could use, dingus

Dredged Yor was cool, so he had to be a warlock. He can't be a hunter because those aren't cool. #WARLOCKMASTERRACE

Cayde-6 doesn't main Hunter that's why

Question. If Yor's cloak wasn't actually his, why is it called his? Why is it not called Pahanins Cloak with a description saying it was stolen? Why is his very own Rose not an artifact of his own class if he is indeed a warlock?

Oh let's be serious for god's sake has there ever been a character in the entirety of Destiny's lore that primarily used a hand cannon, and [i]wasn't[/i] a Hunter? Even the box art. Open and shut.

- there is no rivalry between hunters and warlocks. Not anything more than jokes at least and that is with all classes - he HUNTED his targets - he did take a trophy, pahanin's cloak - it is not confirmed that his gun was converted using hive magic - he did not get corrupted in the same way as other warlocks, as a matter of fact he didn't really get corrupted he just realized that he would always want power that he couldn't get so he was just like "Fuk it" and started killing guardians. - just because he was good at crucible doesn't make him a warlock. Nor does it make him a hunter - there is a HUNTER artifact for him, and he has a cloak named after him and he wore a cloak Not saying he definitely is not a warlock, just trying to show you where some of your points are lacking

[spoiler]Quietly chants "Pujari" in the background.[/spoiler]

You mention shaxx and ikora but they both say cayde walked through the crucible like it was a game Also turning invisible is a prerequisite to blinking seeing as you turn invisible durning it and why is a hunter the only one who has the tech and why dose he share it with other guardians ? Just think caydes stash

Have you read the Reyzl Azzir Grimoire? It's considered to be the card that focuses on Dredgen Yor's transformation, even if there's no direct proof. And Reyzl was a Titan. Just saying...