I would look at FF14 if you're open-minded and ok with a fantasy setting as opposed to shooting. Bad: -It's not a shooter, at all. -It is an MMO. -There is a small monthly subscription fee, but your first month is free and there is offers to make the start up costs nothing. -Can be time consuming in a sense that it can suck you in with how deep it is Good: -It's open world (huuuuuuuge beautiful world) with an absolutely ridiculous amount of things to do. -fantastic story -great music -lots of different raids (>20 man). Extremely well done, look and feel epic with a ton of fairly deep mechanics. -a million smaller dungeons (4 man). Kinda like Destiny Strikes, but done better, in a fantasy setting. -lots of different classes, all of which look and feel unique. -always adding large chunks of new content, class balance, and new things to do. For free. You wouldn't lose anything by just trying it out, maybe you'll like it maybe you won't. Could be a home run if you get into it, could be a bust that doesn't cost you much of anything at all. If that doesn't seem appealing, I would suggest Borderlands (handsome jack collection for current gen). #2 is a phenomenal game with 4 player co-op and has everything on your checklist plus a whole lot more. Great gameplay and the funniest hand I have ever seen/played.