{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
8/26/2025 11:37:44 AM
19
Hunter throwing knife is a MASSIVE problem inside PvP
Here is a clip from my clan mate of me getting obliterated by the Hunter throwing knife even though he misses it, with the most unnatural ricochet! Bungie you need to turn down this knife's damage, the exotic that makes this heavy knife ricochet like that, but most importantly it's severe magnetism. Between this heavy knife, the wombo-combo light weight knife + pistol shot kill and the Hunter electric charge across the ground you have literally made PvP, comp and especially Trials unbearable to play any other class but the Hunter! Please fix this!!!!
-
Edited by Rainbine 9545: 8/29/2025 8:45:09 AMFirst, that is an exotic that’s doing that Second, and in my opinion I don’t really mind the knife as it’s a “meh” thing for me since I have faced it just like you and pretty much shrugged it off when it killed me, plus it’s mostly a guns fault that does it in the first place and I’m going to be real I rather face against that then when I ran into a warlock with reflexes so insane it made hitting them impossible As in I actively started to get annoyed playing against them, not saying it’s a bad thing going against high tiered players but my god does it get infuriating feeling like no matter what you do you can’t do anything, humbling but annoying Also this may come from a hunter, i majority use either the arc melee and the smoke bomb (I throw it either in a path of enemies making it a trap or the less common throwing it in their face)
-
Yeaa it's no different then using a shotgun as a primary. They should've just made it a special weapon for close encounters at the same time buff regular shotgun range and fire rate just a tiny bit to keep it from overtaking it It was not a bad idea but I kinda wished they just started making Legendary 110 or fanframe handcannons instead.
-
1 ReplyI’ve been saying it. The Hunter Knife is not the problematic part of this build. The same technique has existed for years with special shotguns for years The problematic part is the 2 shot primary ammo weapon with better viable range than most shotguns and minimal ease of use issues. They need their PvP range reduced and a potential damage reduction.
-
3 RepliesNah totally balanced. Titans can't 1 hit with shoulder charge, warlocks can't 1 hit with Handheld Nova, but Hunters can have a 1 hit knife that self tracks and bounces off 10 walls and corners to hit. New Shotgun HC and throwing knives is an even bigger issue. You literally have 0.2 seconds to react or your dead and even then your still usually in a tradeoff scenario. Hunters screamed and whined until Titan barricades got nerfed now they are a mile ahead of everyone.
-
3 RepliesHunters literally require no skill to be effective. And if somebody truly skilled is rocking hunter it is damn near impossible to fight back
-
2 RepliesInvise n smokes be lookin better with hindsight, careful what you ask for.
-
2 RepliesSeriously amazes me the number of throwing knife complaints for weeks now. Ricochet knives are nothing new with Athrys and without that tracking on the second bounce would make bouncing the knives effectively useless, so the closest to a valid complaint on Athrys is the OHK to the body which requires multiple rapid crits to proc, usually enough crits that you either should've died or you would've been low enough for an unbuffed knife to kill you anyway. Back to the tracking, they already nerfed it in the past, it needs to bounce at the right angles to lock onto a nearby target whereas you could at one point throw it directly at your feet and it would bounce to the guy 5 meters to the right. They're not going to nerf the damage (especially when the melee stat would no doubt negate the nerf anyway) of Weighted Knife, because it's supposed to be more powerful than the other knives and that's not just because of the OHK to the head. They're not going to remove the tracking on the bounces with Athrys or there'd be no reason to even have the bounces to begin with since no one in their right mind would go for those corner shots otherwise without Hard Light. So the only other change they could feasibly do to Athrys is how quickly you build the buff or how long it lasts. As for the lightweight knives, like I've said in another post, I seriously can't recall a time I've ever seen people complain about these before EOF. And as much as I hate tempest strike users, don't complain about that unless you're also going to complain about warlocks spamming lightning surge or any of the classes spamming similar abilities. There's been no signs of that melee that leaves no time to react to the near if not OHK that is definitely a OHK if it gets multiple people getting a nerf, nor has there been even an announcement for a fix for when your melee misses ever, especially when the enemy is using abilities with CC like Shiver Strike or the Warlock void melee.
-
Too bad we don't have the Stick Around medals anymore like we used to in D1. I had thousands of them.
-
Agreed. It's way OP and needs a nerf.
-
If you are not a Hunter anyways lol. I am sadly not...
-
That was exactly what Arthyrs Embrace is supposed to do, you get consistent head shots to power up the knife allowing for the long range cleanup. It's not popular, and it's certainly not meta, because despite being strong it is highly situational. It's not prevalent in PvP because the knife has a long wind up and is not effective at close range in fast matches. But it does work well against players peak shotting scouts/pulses from the far side of a map...
-
-
1 ReplyDid he have the exotic gloves on? If so this makes plenty of sense
-
Probably athrys embrace. Hunter gauntlets that can make knives do crazy bounces.
-
[quote]Here is a clip from my clan mate of me getting obliterated by the Hunter throwing knife even though he misses it, with the most unnatural ricochet! Bungie you need to turn down this knife's damage, the exotic that makes this heavy knife ricochet like that, but most importantly it's severe magnetism. Between this heavy knife, the wombo-combo light weight knife + pistol shot kill and the Hunter electric charge across the ground you have literally made PvP, comp and especially Trials unbearable to play any other class but the Hunter! Please fix this!!!![/quote] That’s Athrys. It’s been in the game for four years now. You basically never see it.
-
surely this is satire? Athrys is a gimmick exotic that has been in the same for 5ish years now and isn't a problem. You were less than half health in the clip and weighted knife deals 140 to body at base, so not sure what that complaint about damage is for.
-
1 ReplyBest melee class best dual class and best movement class.. when it comes to Balance bungie and its devs has an IQ of a koala
-
Edited by TACO_Adept: 8/27/2025 4:16:40 AMThey love Hunters and Titans, so nothing will happen.. Nerf Hunters smoke but here.. have these knives instead !
-
It's not just throwing knives dude all their melees are busted right now they probably hired another idiot hunter main at Bungie headquarters
