[quote]Technically speaking yes, all classes have their "duty", I agree but there are a prob, first none of the classes and subclasses fit in the role of traditional rpgs, they aren't even oriented to specific rolls[/quote] Voidwalker: mage (more specifically dark mage) class. they have the common life stealing aura around them. Blade dancer: assassin. being hunters, they are already very agile, and they were initially the only subclass that could go invisible. Striker: brute/automaton. just look at how they are built with things such as juggernaut, and etc. Sunsinger: they were supposed to be the paladins, what with song of flame (and the new Viking funeral furthers that statement) Gunslinger: hunter/ranged class Stormcallers: not really sure what you could name them, as classes in RPGs have many differing names for guys like these, but they would be the crowd control class Defender/sunbreaker: tank/brute class Nightstalkers: also assassin class I guess? Look, what I'm trying to say is that each of the subclasses and their abilities already have the traits of RPG classes. Bungie just needs to hone in on them. [quote]that and the odd level up system carry some inconsistencies and overpower loops, while some may be by the way the description is redacted others are evident flaws in the design of the sill tree[/quote] Granted, the leveling system has always been a bit wonky. Up until HOW, a guardian had no control of what they utilized, and how they got to end game tier. The only way to become end game tier/level was to beat the raid at the time. And thus, everyone looked the exact same. But bungie has learned from their mistakes (slowly but surely no doubt) they implemented etheric light in HOW, and now we have infusion here in TTK. They are honestly getting better through trial and error. And if anything, this system seems to be the best. In year 1; if an enemy was 1 level higher than you; they'd have a 30% increase in about everything. Now one light level is pretty inconsequential. But now, that means there is no drive for end game... all they need is a few more tweaks, and boom; the leveling will be fine [quote] finally the guns also meet nerfs, and that's ironic even paradoxical because they created a system where items are classified by rarity and being the rarest the more powerful. fact the game have more legendary items that common, uncommon, rare and exotic items all thogether, so that..."legendary" thing is just a placebo fact #2 99.99% will use the most overpowered item they can get, same goes for subclasses, that's obvious, the problem is that bungie didn't tested its game well enough, because many combos appeared in just a couple of weeks that where clearly overpowered, but they let it be[/quote] When it has come to guns in this game; many of the nerfs have only come from the pvp community. (And let's be honest, a few of them needed it). and then a few tweaks for the god weapons (IE: fatebringer, VOC, ghorn, icebreaker, black hammer, etc) But again; if bungie implements a system where there is no right op answer. But rather, where everything has its own pros and cons, nerfs for guns will dissipate as well. Hand cannons will be perfect in close quarters. But you must be a skilled shot, and anyone outside of optimal range will win Autos will also be perfect in close quarters and will cause less pacing shots. However, anything out of range will kill you, and you must have high control of your weapon for sustainable damage Pulse rifles will be the best in mid range. But against a hand cannon or auto in close range; they will almost always fail. The same would go in a fire fight against a scout in far range. Scouts would be the greatest option for long range combat, but would require a steady hand. Especially for consistent success in close/mid range Shot guns would never get a kill out of extreme close range Snipers would work their best in far range. And even then; would require the most precise of hands Fusions would be gods in mid range And sidearms would be a fusion's only competition In my format, their would be no need for nerfs, because nothing is op. Some weapons and abilities just work better than others in a certain contingency. [quote]fact #3 many of those combos where intentional but then when you analyze it you have a list of "must have" exotics for each class, with two or more subclass specific perks, then you have the "not-so-exotic" which have only one perk, so then you see the "imbalance" bungie try so hard to correct is created by their own incompetence[/quote] That's what I'm getting at. If they implemented the format I'm proposing; there would be nothing that would give anyone any form of leverage. A guardian would choose the parts of their arsenal based on what they feel comfortable with, and what scenarios they see themselves constantly returning to. Not just "whip out thorn because two shots to the head = game over" The only way something would be seen as op is if the player has perfected their playstyle with said oddity. And it would still only work for the situations advantageous to them.