It's certainly a logical approach to balance but your basic premise that shoulder charge is OP, dominating crucible, and even more inexplicably, [i]has no counter[/i] is fatally flawed. And the nerf to [i]throwing knives[/i] is the problem? That's just insane, I'm sorry. We don't need to come up with a counter to shoulder charge anyway, it already exists: Shottys are a definite hard counter to shoulder charge, as opposed to, say, hardscoping down a hallway and forgetting that your radar exists. Conclusion: [b]You're making the same mistake[/b], trying to do something about shoulder charge, which is in no way OP but is actually a good counter to what's really ailing PvP right now, which is campy sniping bullshit play. One thing we don't need is to slow things down even further!