I'm neutral. They wanted to create something they never done before, bring an mmo type shooter to consoles which I'm not sure has really been done before, while also delivering it to all consoles which they also haven't done before. I don't think they quite knew how to hit that mark they set for themselves, or had enough time to. With activison as the publisher I'm pretty certain they pushed to have the game drop when it did. The game is not perfect but there is clearly something here considering how upset everyone is but they continue to log hundreds of hours... Edit - a side note. I am a little dissapointed at their patching (or lack thereof) when it comes to bugs... But that's my only gripe.