{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
8/17/2012 6:33:27 AM
38
Are Brutes related to humans?
It would make more sense, I mean its a huge coincidence that evolution on a completely separate planet would give rise to apes like it did on Earth. Could the precursors have tampered with the evolution? Its also strange how all the planets have the same kind of plants.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] grey101 [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] H0FFman J [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] grey101 Even though everybody here is mocking you OP in Primordium states there were [b]hundreds[/b] of types of "humans" that would under all sorts of subcategories and classes. I think it would be a highly interesting twist of the brutes were part of the hundreds of "humans' that were reseeded and are indeed genetically related to humanity. [/quote] If brutes are related to humans and are reseeded by forerunners, shouldn't they show up as forerunner artifacts on luminaries and be able to use [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ddliR8USdGg&feature=player_detailpage#t=162s]forerunner technology[/url]?[/quote] Do we know if chimps and other apes show up on forerunner tech? The humans from Erda were the only ones to have Gea which is why they probably show up on forerunner technology as a warning/notification. Um, Humans are the only ones that can use the rings and possibly shield worlds not forerunner technology in general. That probably steams from them being related as humans [b]and[/b] forerunners were needed to control forerunner tech att eh end of primodium. [/quote] Oh... That explains it quite nicely.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] H0FFman J [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] grey101 Even though everybody here is mocking you OP in Primordium states there were [b]hundreds[/b] of types of "humans" that would under all sorts of subcategories and classes. I think it would be a highly interesting twist of the brutes were part of the hundreds of "humans' that were reseeded and are indeed genetically related to humanity. [/quote] If brutes are related to humans and are reseeded by forerunners, shouldn't they show up as forerunner artifacts on luminaries and be able to use [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ddliR8USdGg&feature=player_detailpage#t=162s]forerunner technology[/url]?[/quote] Do we know if chimps and other apes show up on forerunner tech? The humans from Erda were the only ones to have Gea which is why they probably show up on forerunner technology as a warning/notification. Um, Humans are the only ones that can use the rings and possibly shield worlds not forerunner technology in general. That probably steams from them being related as humans [b]and[/b] forerunners were needed to control forerunner tech att eh end of primodium.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] grey101 Even though everybody here is mocking you OP in Primordium states there were [b]hundreds[/b] of types of "humans" that would under all sorts of subcategories and classes. I think it would be a highly interesting twist of the brutes were part of the hundreds of "humans' that were reseeded and are indeed genetically related to humanity. [/quote] If brutes are related to humans and are reseeded by forerunners, shouldn't they show up as forerunner artifacts on luminaries and be able to use [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ddliR8USdGg&feature=player_detailpage#t=162s]forerunner technology[/url]?
-
brutes are ursine, meaning bears.
-
Yes. It explains why they pull down/up their non-existent pants [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2600oOJqcqg]when taking a piss[/url]. It explains why they eat their non-existent food while maintaining [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zQmRqr4jEj4#t=2m9s]good table manners[/url]. It explains why [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YweIlPNcCD4#t=33s]they beat their chests like a gorilla[/url]. It explains why they use their fists instead of the bladed edge of their weapons. It explains why they have a profound love of powerful human weapons. And it explains why they make orgasm noises when you touch them.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cmdr DaeFaron [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Spartan1995324 [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Master_Beta And the reason the plants look so similar is the same reason plants in china look simmilar to the plants in south america. But with some variations due to having to evolve to the habitat.[/quote]Except you know... Plants in South America and China are on the same planet. Continental drift can apply in this case and they share the same atmosphere basically. Plants on Doisac cannot have continental drift applied to them because the two planets don't share continents. Also, the plants had to grow under 2G conditions which would drastically change they way they grow.[/quote] And what little of Doisac we saw can be summed up as "Do we want to develop a number of strange, new plants for a scene that is not very long at all... or just make some typical looking ones?" Cause we've only seen Doisac in Origins right? Same reason for say, ME or star wars/star trek to have planets covered in earth-looking trees.[/quote]That's the REAL reason why the plants look similar. The fellow I quoted said the reason was the same as the reason why some plants in South America and China are similar. That's not the reason why the plants are similar. The reason is the one you posted.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Spartan1995324 [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Master_Beta And the reason the plants look so similar is the same reason plants in china look simmilar to the plants in south america. But with some variations due to having to evolve to the habitat.[/quote]Except you know... Plants in South America and China are on the same planet. Continental drift can apply in this case and they share the same atmosphere basically. Plants on Doisac cannot have continental drift applied to them because the two planets don't share continents. Also, the plants had to grow under 2G conditions which would drastically change they way they grow.[/quote] And what little of Doisac we saw can be summed up as "Do we want to develop a number of strange, new plants for a scene that is not very long at all... or just make some typical looking ones?" Cause we've only seen Doisac in Origins right? Same reason for say, ME or star wars/star trek to have planets covered in earth-looking trees.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Master_Beta And the reason the plants look so similar is the same reason plants in china look simmilar to the plants in south america. But with some variations due to having to evolve to the habitat.[/quote]Except you know... Plants in South America and China are on the same planet. Continental drift can apply in this case and they share the same atmosphere basically. Plants on Doisac cannot have continental drift applied to them because the two planets don't share continents. Also, the plants had to grow under 2G conditions which would drastically change they way they grow.
-
I could be wrong but the answer is no.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Gamma617g Wow. Didn't think people in this thread would be that stupid. Brutes are decidedly NOT apes as something that evolved on a planet in an isolated star system. In fact, Brutes would have no analog at all in Earth fauna. That's how aliens work guys.[/quote] You are the one that is rather ignorant. I clearly said that it wouldn't be impossible for them to be a type of human with the recent Primordium knowledge.
-
Wow. Didn't think people in this thread would be that stupid. Brutes are decidedly NOT apes as something that evolved on a planet in an isolated star system. In fact, Brutes would have no analog at all in Earth fauna. That's how aliens work guys.
-
Nope.
-
They are a large bipedial 'ape like' species. it doesn't mean that they are directly related to apes. But it doesn't mean that they are not related to humans. Maybe a guy with goliath syndrome or whatever f***ed a monkey? and the 'creators' decided to go through with it. And the reason the plants look so similar is the same reason plants in china look simmilar to the plants in south america. But with some variations due to having to evolve to the habitat.
-
That seems very unlikely.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cmdr DaeFaron [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Skulblaka [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] grey101 Even though everybody here is mocking you OP in Primordium states there were [b]hundreds[/b] of types of "humans" that would under all sorts of subcategories and classes. I think it would be a highly interesting twist of the brutes were part of the hundreds of "humans' that were reseeded and are indeed genetically related to humanity. Hell, i once -in private entertained myself with the idea that a large brute ship crashed on earth eons ago and that is where the origin of "bigfoot" came from. Which isn't all too odd since Marah in Primordium was indeed of human relation and was the ape we think bigfoot might be.[/quote] You might be on to something here... I think it's definitely possible that the Brutes are related to the Humans. There are clearly several similarities that humans don't share with any of the other Covenant species. They're relatively humanoid, similar jaw structure and grow hair. [/quote] That's kinda like saying humans and Asari in Mass Effect are related, since they share physical similarities.... Not denying your theory though.[/quote] Asari are blue and have head tentacles :P I just think it's plausible that Brutes are another form of humans, a very distant relation of -blam!- Sapiens. [/quote] And brutes are easily 3 feet taller, far more muscular, and have a fairly different skull if I may say so :P. I personally am not seeing the relation between the two.[/quote] Physical differences mean nothing as we share 50 percent of our genes with bananas and we look absolutely nothing alike.
-
Idk, but probably not since they're in different parts of the universe.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Skulblaka [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cmdr DaeFaron [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Skulblaka [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] grey101 Even though everybody here is mocking you OP in Primordium states there were [b]hundreds[/b] of types of "humans" that would under all sorts of subcategories and classes. I think it would be a highly interesting twist of the brutes were part of the hundreds of "humans' that were reseeded and are indeed genetically related to humanity. Hell, i once -in private entertained myself with the idea that a large brute ship crashed on earth eons ago and that is where the origin of "bigfoot" came from. Which isn't all too odd since Marah in Primordium was indeed of human relation and was the ape we think bigfoot might be.[/quote] You might be on to something here... I think it's definitely possible that the Brutes are related to the Humans. There are clearly several similarities that humans don't share with any of the other Covenant species. They're relatively humanoid, similar jaw structure and grow hair. [/quote] That's kinda like saying humans and Asari in Mass Effect are related, since they share physical similarities.... Not denying your theory though.[/quote] Asari are blue and have head tentacles :P I just think it's plausible that Brutes are another form of humans, a very distant relation of -blam!- Sapiens. [/quote] And brutes are easily 3 feet taller, far more muscular, and have a fairly different skull if I may say so :P. I personally am not seeing the relation between the two.
-
-_____- NO!
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Avatar Korra [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] TheSpiderChief No, they're not related to humans. They're not even apes.[/quote][/quote]
-
Bigfoot is actually a Brute.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cmdr DaeFaron [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Skulblaka [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] grey101 Even though everybody here is mocking you OP in Primordium states there were [b]hundreds[/b] of types of "humans" that would under all sorts of subcategories and classes. I think it would be a highly interesting twist of the brutes were part of the hundreds of "humans' that were reseeded and are indeed genetically related to humanity. Hell, i once -in private entertained myself with the idea that a large brute ship crashed on earth eons ago and that is where the origin of "bigfoot" came from. Which isn't all too odd since Marah in Primordium was indeed of human relation and was the ape we think bigfoot might be.[/quote] You might be on to something here... I think it's definitely possible that the Brutes are related to the Humans. There are clearly several similarities that humans don't share with any of the other Covenant species. They're relatively humanoid, similar jaw structure and grow hair. [/quote] That's kinda like saying humans and Asari in Mass Effect are related, since they share physical similarities.... Not denying your theory though.[/quote] Asari are blue and have head tentacles :P I just think it's plausible that Brutes are another form of humans, a very distant relation of -blam!- Sapiens.
-
Watch Planet of the Apes. That explains everything quite nicely.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Skulblaka [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] grey101 Even though everybody here is mocking you OP in Primordium states there were [b]hundreds[/b] of types of "humans" that would under all sorts of subcategories and classes. I think it would be a highly interesting twist of the brutes were part of the hundreds of "humans' that were reseeded and are indeed genetically related to humanity. Hell, i once -in private entertained myself with the idea that a large brute ship crashed on earth eons ago and that is where the origin of "bigfoot" came from. Which isn't all too odd since Marah in Primordium was indeed of human relation and was the ape we think bigfoot might be.[/quote] You might be on to something here... I think it's definitely possible that the Brutes are related to the Humans. There are clearly several similarities that humans don't share with any of the other Covenant species. They're relatively humanoid, similar jaw structure and grow hair. [/quote] That's kinda like saying humans and Asari in Mass Effect are related, since they share physical similarities.... Not denying your theory though. [Edited on 08.18.2012 11:49 AM PDT]
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] grey101 Even though everybody here is mocking you OP in Primordium states there were [b]hundreds[/b] of types of "humans" that would under all sorts of subcategories and classes. I think it would be a highly interesting twist of the brutes were part of the hundreds of "humans' that were reseeded and are indeed genetically related to humanity. Hell, i once -in private entertained myself with the idea that a large brute ship crashed on earth eons ago and that is where the origin of "bigfoot" came from. Which isn't all too odd since Marah in Primordium was indeed of human relation and was the ape we think bigfoot might be.[/quote] You might be on to something here... I think it's definitely possible that the Brutes are related to the Humans. There are clearly several similarities that humans don't share with any of the other Covenant species. They're relatively humanoid, similar jaw structure and grow hair.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] CoolCJ24 Could have had a common ancestor I guess (by that, I mean the Precursors created both from a common ancestor). Unlikely but not impossible. I mean, humans share a lot of DNA (upwards of 99% I think) with silver-back gorillas and at first glance we are fairly different.[/quote]Except Brutes aren't ALL ape like. They share features with Rhinos and Bears.
-
not likely
