{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
2/13/2012 8:10:44 AM
59
Why was Anakin not granted the rank of Master?
If you think about it, he's achieved more than some of the other council members, yet still didn't get the rank.
Anakin had his own padawan and even defeated Darth Tyranus alone. Defeating a Sith lord should be an instant rank of Master, yet he wasn't granted the rank. Why did they deny it from him? They did state he was a bit young but Mace Windu and Obi Wan aren't far off. To be honest, if you set episodes 4, 5 and 6 aside, if he were to have gotten this rank, Sidious's plan would have failed.
Sidious was expecting the council to deny him his mastership, although if this were to happen, he wouldn't be able to give Anakin leverage against the Jedi council.
-
palpatinesbehinditall
-
He did do remarkable things, but his mentality about the force was wrong. He wanted to use it for the power it gave him
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Recon Number 54 Wars not make one great. Decided by who one kills, a Jedi's greatness is not. If emotional, impulsive, reckless a Jedi is, then a Master they are not. A Master of one's self a Jedi must be. While a recognition the title of Master may be, such things a Jedi desires not.[/quote] This is win right there.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] AquaBlader The Jedi had it right. The Council was the seat of wisdom in the Jedi Order. Anakin displayed a lack of this trait in most of the movies. Also, guys, how the hell do people die at childbirth in the damn StarWars universe? (this is refering to Anakin's dreams, not to the fact that he choked the living -blam!- out of his wife)[/quote] They lose the will to live. WTF that means I have no idea. I think it was just Lucas making a cop out, couldn't think of a good reason to kill her. Most people can't, Portman is hot.
-
he wasn't ready and he was young
-
The Jedi had it right. The Council was the seat of wisdom in the Jedi Order. Anakin displayed a lack of this trait in most of the movies. Also, guys, how the hell do people die at childbirth in the damn StarWars universe? (this is refering to Anakin's dreams, not to the fact that he choked the living -blam!- out of his wife) [Edited on 02.13.2012 1:48 PM PST]
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] EL Wait a sec... who says he wasn't a Master? [url=http://youtu.be/ZO9YuGhRDLo]Plot hole or confused kid?[/url][/quote] Vader was a good old friend.
-
He was too young, and still have too many 'issues' (Yoda could sense his anger about the loss of his mother, and he was 'secretly' in-love) The council could sense this, and in result denied him his rank as a test. Obi-Wan said, the council are being cautious because he had acheived so much so soon, and that he should be patient as it won't be long. The test turned out to be necessary, as it was kinda his last. And who is them Padawan you speak of? Your not refering to the Clone Wars cartoon are you? I'm not sure if that is considered true canon. (cause it was upheld within the movies. Movie canon > else) I've watched a bit of Clone Wars, and I've seen other bits that conflict with movie canon.
-
Wars not make one great. Decided by who one kills, a Jedi's greatness is not. If emotional, impulsive, reckless a Jedi is, then a Master they are not. A Master of one's self a Jedi must be. While a recognition the title of Master may be, such things a Jedi desires not.
-
Isn't it obvious it was because of his immaturity? Yoda saw the hate thing coming since Episode 1.
-
Because the council be trollin'
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] EL Wait a sec... who says he wasn't a Master? [url=http://youtu.be/ZO9YuGhRDLo]Plot hole or confused kid?[/url][/quote]I was expecting Anakin to react to that remark. Such as say he isn't a master, but wished he was.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] EL Wait a sec... who says he wasn't a Master? [url=http://youtu.be/ZO9YuGhRDLo]Plot hole or confused kid?[/url][/quote]misread line more likely the counsel(yoda) said explicitly that he wasn't a master
-
Wait a sec... who says he wasn't a Master? [url=http://youtu.be/ZO9YuGhRDLo]Plot hole or confused kid?[/url]
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] chubbz Lumiya was Darth Vaders padawan at one point? intredasting.jpg[/quote] Slightly fixed
-
Too unstable. While he had the skills to be a master, he lacked the emotional discipline.
-
-_- [Edited on 02.13.2012 1:24 PM PST]
-
Lumiya was Anakin's padawan at one point? intredasting.jpg
-
Because he was a little -blam!-. According to the Council he had too much fear and anger and he had to deal with that first.
-
He cut off Darth Tyranus' hands before beheading him. Doesn't seem like the actions of a Jedi.
-
One does not earn the rank of master, one becomes a master.
-
he was a whiny bich, that's why. he didn't even deserve to on the counsel at all, he should have been grateful. [Edited on 02.13.2012 1:16 PM PST]
-
He sucked.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] The Kangol Kid [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Seggi31 Because he was angry, impatient and emotional.[/quote] You totally misspelled "whiny -blam!-"[/quote] I actually laughed aloud. haha
-
Being a Jedi Master has nothing to do with the amount of pwnage you can dish out.
-
[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] SniPeng salt He had a padawan??[/quote] Asoka or something. In the Clone Wars.
