{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
5/9/2020 1:07:44 AM
29
Which crucible is better?
I’ve been playing destiny since the d1 beta. I played a lot d1 crucible compared to d2. And recently I’ve been going back to d1 cause there’s something about it that d2 just doesn’t have. I noticed tho that d1 is a lot more fun and balanced compared to d2, every gun is a viable option, there’s no “meta”, and one doesn’t dominate the other. But I want to know if you had to choose, which one would you play?
English
#destiny2
-
3 RepliesWhat is the difference between D1 MM and D2 MM?
-
5 RepliesThe arena in that lost sector on Tangled shore
-
D1 had better loot from PvP. But I overall enjoy the gameplay of D2 pvp more.
-
1 ReplyI see the nostalgia is strong on the votes. Guess everyone forgot about the BS which coincidentally is why the game was the way it was at launch. All “feedback” wether direct or indirect. There was most certainly a meta. In fact just about every type of weapon had it’s time on top. What is hilarious is that D2 is repeating that as well with only a few types left for their turn.
-
D1 has better maps and the graphics feel crispy.
-
Vanilla d2 was more enjoyable than this currently
-
7 RepliesEveryone who says D1 Crucible, does not remember it.
-
D1 had better control over your subclasses. I like the control over my armor builds more in D2 though. I’m going to have to go with D2 right now since I can still crutch on my special weapon and win gunfights I shouldn’t. D1 was more balanced when it comes to the special ammo economy though.
-
1 ReplyThey're both kinda shit.
-
I miss the large maps from D1. Some of the modes were fun occassionally like rift or zone control.
-
felt like there were way more viable options in D1
-
1 ReplyBest memory from D1 Crucible: I got Ghorn from an Iron Banner game after being at the top of the leaderboard. Best memory from D2 Crucible: I got matched against BAGaming and got owned.
-
1 ReplyEdited by Bumblebee793: 5/9/2020 11:58:08 PMOne time in d2 y1 iron banner it was 3v3 and all 3 enemies were trying to take our zone so i went invisible while they obliterated my teamate and I took the heavy ammo block that just spawned right next to them. They didnt last long after that. (Also I was using Graviton forfeit so thats why my invis lasted so long.)
-
6 RepliesEdited by AppleSoda: 5/9/2020 3:47:15 PMSo this is secretly a poll to illustrate how many people are completely blinded by nostalgia and how many people are somewhat sane? Right... please tell me the 50ish % that voted D1 are joking. Please...
-
2 RepliesThere was absolutely a meta in D1. And a lot of things that were straight up annoying. MIDA, constant MIDA Insta kill stickies Thorn Shinobu's.. oh look those are back and still annoying. I do miss parts of it (like being able to switch weapons without waiting 15 seconds for the menu) but there was definitely enough cheese to go around in D1 crucible. The nostalgia hits harder than the reality of it imo.
-
So are we talking Y1, 2 or 3 D1 crucible Cause i pick Yr2 Yr1 crucible was basically dominated by exotics Y2 is when legendary weapons could become the true meta
-
Year 2 destiny 1 was the best.
-
Year 1 D2 for ever! [spoiler]Unlease the Hounds![/spoiler]
-
I think d2's crucible is definitely better, though I definitely remember d1's more fondly because the guns just felt more fun to use. Same with a lot of subclass abilities.
-
D1 pre special ammo nerf.
-
7 RepliesIf you think the d1 meta we left off with is better than current d2 you are just crazy. d1 year 3 was just ice breaker, sidearm, no land beyond hell as people did all they could to find workarounds to have special ammo without actually getting ammo. Primaries were so bad that sticky grenades were really the most effective way to kill someone. Sniper and shotguns had undergone nerf after nerf as well as the torched special economy. The game was just unplayable. Talk about early forsaken and you might have a point. I just feel like the D2 meta we have now is really not that bad aside from a couple outliers but honestly theres a wide variety of good weapons and weapon types, subclasses, and exotics.
-
1 ReplyEdited by Swiftlock: 5/9/2020 5:27:34 PMDestiny 1 - specifically the HoW-TTK era. If autos got a small buff and exotic hand cannons were toned down a little, it would've been as close to perfect as we could get. But for the most part, all primary archetypes had an option that had bite to them, even pulses and scouts.
-
Edited by hate n payne: 5/9/2020 4:57:31 PMDestiny 1 for sure. D2 Crucible has been cancerous since day one. Not Y3 D1 though, that crap was garbage.
-
If I could pick up ammo from defeated players in D1 then it'd be a 100% better Crucible overall since the only thing holding it back is everyone defaulting to Icebreaker for the ammo regeneration.
-
Dark age crucible. Muthas were killed in cold blood... Shaxx was even a combatant... Beat the crap out of felwinter. Good times
-
2 RepliesMayhem is available rn in D1. Omg I had fun playing last night. Hrs of fun. I teared up a bit. Then played KF and had a blast with randoms who felt like long time friends. God I miss the feeling D1 gave me.
