{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
Edited by TwoMagsGone:
9/13/2019 4:54:54 PM
39
A Titan's opinion on Throwing Knives
I say let the bottom tree Knife Juggler One Hit to the head for a season.
This can give hunters a OHK ability that already requires skill and restrict it down to the OG 3 Shot GG. It's a skill shot anyways and I'd say it won't be too broken, just don't run right at the guy and most of us should be fine.
-
2 RepliesI'd take 1 hit kill tripmines back instead
-
Warlock Main: Agreed, and also give back the damage to Tripmines to let them OHKO people and stick to foreheads again. Anyone who hears that sound of a tripmine and still walks into it- it's there own fault if they die to it. Be it not paying attention, or just ignoring it. I remember when Trips would kill on activation. When you couldn't run through it and laugh as you took little to no damage.
-
1 ReplyHow do you delete someone else's post?
-
Edited by HollowedWayfarer: 9/16/2019 5:38:25 AMNot Juggler, but definitely Explosive Knife on a precision kill. Maybe even Knife Trick if you manage to land all three knives on the head. Or at the very least make Tripmines a OHK
-
13 RepliesOnly if throwing hammers do the same only fair right?
-
8 RepliesHunters have enough cheap abilities...they dont need more
-
Agreed. Titan main.
-
Edited by WulfPak666: 9/15/2019 7:49:32 PMI feel the throwing knife has a bit too much "ehh close enough" aim assist, especially at range to warrent it being a 1hk. So how about this? Top Tree Throwing Knife augment. * Hold R1 (or whatever button you use) to charge you knife with solar energy. Hitting a target with a precious hit deals massive damage (1hk on Guardians except supers) at the cost of a longer cooldown. This way you'll get your "one and done" hard hitting melee and then we can all -blam!- and cry over which is more OP, Shoulder Charge, Solar Knife or Handheld Super Nova.
-
1 ReplyAs a Hunter main, I'd love to have this but only if it's conditional, otherwise it would be OP especially on bottom tree. In line with the general Hunter fantasy, I would only make it an OHK on crit if the target doesn't see me. Since we don't have invisibility on that subclass, that would have to mean a sneak attack from behind, the side, or above. Should give a means to counter in 1v1 by just facing the hunter, and play into the hunter/prey fantasy. Other options might be to have it charge like a handheld supernova on top-tree, narrow the spread significantly on middle-tree, or even have the three knives thrown in sequence when charged, also on middle tree - both would require that all three have to hit to secure a kill, say 64/knife or so.
-
5 RepliesThen I want a throwing fist.
-
I agree hunters need them. I am a warlock main
-
just let us charge the knife and a headshot kills
-
Guardians are supposed to be powerful after all. I’m all for this. [spoiler]Titan main[/spoiler]
-
-
Just make a OHK throwing knife be like drawing a bow shot 👍
-
1 ReplyEdited by RPColten: 9/13/2019 11:28:17 PMWhat if bottom tree had a passive buff on the Sharpshooters trance in which precision hits (from knives or weapons) buff the precision damage of the throwing knife? Right now Sharpshooters Trance just provides slight recharge to the super. E: Right now the bottom tree knife is largely irrelevant to the subclass tree. It's pointless when special weapons can be used for more effective damage, and it requires a kill to be a consistent and reliable damage source (which still falls short from special weapons). The shoulder charge on bottom tree Sentinel will be getting a suppression effect, so why can't bottom tree throwing knife get a ramping damage buff that makes sense in the context of the subclass and rewards consistent aim?
-
5 RepliesI don't know why they even took it out of the game. Never heard one person complain about it.
-
I see no reason not to.
-
4 RepliesI never had an issue with OHK Throwing Knives in D1. As you stated, took some skill and I never felt bad being taken out like that, especially at a distance. Agreed and I say give it back to the Hunters. - A Titan
-
3 RepliesHow are people in here complaining about how this would be op while meanwhile titans get a free one shot melees that don't even require precision like this would -_-
-
How about if you had to cook the knife for s little while to increase its damage? That would make sense.
-
2 RepliesNooo way. As a hunter main, they ability to have a ranged 1 shot melee that refreshes with no exotic is op. There should be an exotic to hold down melee to charge the knife, release it and it can 1 shot but doesn’t refresh. There needs to be a trade off
-
The people who upvote these kinds of threads are most likely dogshit pvp players. Throwing knife has little risk as opposed to SC or even Supernova.
-
25 RepliesI’d actually prefer mid arc staff to ohk
-
2 RepliesYou say you're a titan yet you made a warlock as your first character. [spoiler]You're Not A Real Titan.[/spoiler]
-
Ophidia spathe would make it broken af so no
