Tried to drop my light level, bought greens and dropped to 205. Tried to restart the game several times; its been 4 days since I killed Gaul. Bought 4 sparrows from Amanda. Ran 2 heroic strikes and 12+ normal strikes. Light level 258. Tried to have someone else queue us for Nightfall, wasnt able (because I havent unlocked). Dont have a story line quest to do, tells me to do a Nightfall. I never paid attention to the milestones because this is my first toon in D2; I wasnt concerned about NF at the time, so I have no idea when it bugged or what step I was on.