The silent guardian would be fine if there weren't questions directed at us that require a response. The cringe when zavalla asks "What do you say gaurdian?" and you just look at your ghost like "holy shit, he can see me?" was a perfect example of bad writing for a silent protagonist. If zavalla had simply said "Are you in gaurdian?" then a nod would have been a suitable response. Bungie needs to work on the dialogue a lot.
English
-
I think that Bungie we’re trying to have the characters address us personally, so like we’d answer that. If you get what I mean
-
I get what you're saying. Just like blues clues and dora the explorer.
-
Yeah exactly
-
Frankly I'd rather have Dora's talking map as a sidekick wayyyy more than Nolanbot
-
Thats a solid "maybe" from me.
-
It was scenes like that that made me think our guardians were originally meant to have dialogue, but everything got cut last minute... again.
-
I laughed so hard I died and now travel the world with a ghost. #SoonToBeSilenced
-
Or if zavala had said anything along the lines of "do what you want guardian, I won't force this on you". And you don't make any gestures, you just DO IT.
-
"holy shit, he can see me?" The long laugh I needed. Perfect description.
-
[quote]"Are you in gaurdian?" [/quote] I'd like to be in guardian ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
-
[quote]The silent guardian would be fine if there weren't questions directed at us that require a response. The cringe when zavalla asks "What do you say gaurdian?" and you just look at your ghost like "holy shit, he can see me?" was a perfect example of bad writing for a silent protagonist. If zavalla had simply said "Are you in gaurdian?" then a nod would have been a suitable response. Bungie needs to work on the dialogue a lot.[/quote] Exactly! A silent main character can work if it's done well. Don't ask me a question in first person view then switch to third person extreme close up of my face just to have silence or my ghost speak.
-
[quote]...and you just look at your ghost like "holy shit, he can see me?" [/quote] [b]LOL[/b] You win the forums today
-
I've never had so many likes on one comment, so you might be right.
-
Because it’s hilariously poignant. Every single person who read that instantly visualized that comment so clearly it may was well be cannon.
-
-
Our guardians thought they had mastered the ability to become invisible to the naked eye by standing extremely still.
-
They can't see us if we move v e r y s l o w l y.
-
Lol I’m Drax
-
Zavala: "I see dead people" Plus "I don't need a key, I transcend time and space"
-
-
"Holy shit, he can see me?" That statement made my day, thank you..
-
Agreed
-
Well said. Little things like this really make or break your immersion and attachment to the characters driving the story.
-
That right there. If the writers could write it t make sense it wouldn’t be so cringe worthy. They have shown they do not possess this talent thus far.
-
"Holy shit he can see me" hahahahaha