I'm going to attempt to use an analogy (albeit it's not perfect) to help those who may not understand how a P2P network (hybrid or not) works vs Dedicated Servers....
P2P (no matter who the host is - even if it's Bungie) acts like those old Christmas lights that run in "series".... any one light (client) that has trouble will substantially affect the entire series, worse yet if you have several lights causing problems they compound to blow the fuse (close as I could get to the effect) ...
Conversely Dedicated Servers work like Christmas lights in "parallel" meaning if one light has issues, it doesn't effect the rest of the strand of lights at all (it's issue is isolated from affecting the rest of the lights). Hope that makes sense?
So if your lights are still put together "in series" no matter who the "chief light" is (ie. the host controlling physics, etc) in that "series" you are still going to be affected in the same way when one, or any, or all the lights have issues just like before. And the more lights that have issues, the bigger the problems are going to be, because their problems compound in a P2P series.
Opinion: It's disappointing to see Bungie mislead its customer base time and time again. It's as if the are running a shell game on the streets of New York and they keep suckering us in to keep betting....and why is that? It's because we have hope we'll finally get the game it should be, a game that Bungie holds back from reaching its full potential.....OR at minimum we want to believe they aren't really cheating or lying to us.
Bottom line, It's up to us to voice our discontent loud enough that Bungie/Activision fix these glaring and substantial issues. Sadly, it appears that they don't or won't improve anything until it threatens their bottom line; because customers are no longer "snowed" by their myriad of half truths, broken commitments, and outright lies. Make Destiny Great!
English
#Destiny
-
21 RepliesOkay. Let's talk about dedicated servers, using your analogy: Say you bought those Christmas lights, the ones where one light can go out, but the rest stay on. You're happy with them, they're bright and (almost) everlasting. But then you get a letter in the mail about a month later from the store you purchased the lights from. Turns out that if you wish to continue to have the lights up, you will have to pay a service fee to ensure that the lights remain up on your house. This is terrible news; you're already paying the electricity bill, so why do you need to pay for this service fee? You send a reply back with these questions, to which they answer saying that this is the standard for these kinds of Christmas lights. They may be amazing, but if they do not get services frequently, they will all short out and never turn on again. Had you bought the other lights, the store would easily repair those ones for free at no further charge. [spoiler]To basically summarise: - Bungie gets dedicated servers. - Bungie pays for use of servers. - Bungie eventually loses money due to lack of funds, thanks to servers. - Bungie has to incur a subscription fee to cover the costs. - Destiny 2 loses players due to quitters not wanting to pay. - Servers are shut down due to lack of paying players. - No more Destiny 2.[/spoiler] Also, in before you mention the "billions" they made from Destiny 1. It costs money to make money and the "billions" they made were used to cover the costs of making, promoting and running the game, the business and everything in between.