Tough Love time.
Take a break from the herd mentality for a few minutes and think about how much this actually affects you and your friends. Given that 99% of you have linked accounts, the answer is most likely "not very much." A few things I believe this is not:
This is not an attempt to censor bad press about Destiny. As much as Bungie has the right to control what content appears on their website, they don't use it for active censorship. Some of the most damning criticism of their products is hosted on this very site, and available for the public to see. And let's be honest; the game has been out for more than a year; the only people who still care enough to complain about the game are people who are playing the game.
This is not an attempt to extort money. As DeeJ said, less than 1% of us will be affected. They wouldn't take an action, let alone an action with the chance to stir up so much hate, to secure such a small number of sales. In addition, the notion is irrelevant, as a user can download the Destiny demo for [i]free[/i] with a [i]free[/i] XBL/PSN account, and create a Bungie.net account for [i]free[/i] to link it with. As long as you have an internet connection and a console that Bungie has developed for in the last 8 years, you can post here for [i]free.[/i]
I believe what this really is is an honest attempt to clean up the forums.
I have been here for a very long time, and I have seen many different moderation styles on this website. My first ban was for having an off-topic conversation in a thread (with the older layouts, this actually cluttered things up). There were about two dozen active forum moderators at the time. This was before we could embed pictures or videos, or even use (non-text) emoticons.
As it stands, the game this website currently services is reported to have around 17,000,000 active users. If even 10% of them were active on the website at any given time, it would be way too much of a burden for 24 volunteer moderators to handle. Automated systems were put in place to handle this workload, but the general consensus is that they aren't getting the job done. It's extremely easy to create alt accounts, and moderators don't seem to have the resources to shut down prolonged attacks.
Requiring linked accounts to post to the mains is a step against this. Granted, it can be maliciously bypassed quite easily, but it will discourage some, and improve the level of enforcement that can be delivered to those that do so (bans from the game itself). Most importantly, it gives the authorities more tools to track down the worst offenders.
So who does this affect?
A handful of aging NEETs who are drawn by nostalgia to Babby's First /b/ (#offtopic). I am sorry, but this website and this community does not owe them anything. In addition, they can retain their current level of access for free with minimal effort, it will ultimately just be slightly more tedious for them to evade bans. Such inhuman tragedy. Even if it weren't free, all it would mean is that they aren't allowed to post on the website of a company they haven't given any money to (barring store purchases) in the last 5 years.
But wait, B.net actually is still catering to such people. They still have their accounts, and they can still post in private groups. You read that right; Bungie is letting people that don't even buy their games create their own private forums for free. So greedy.
And even if these users are too cool to play a AAA mainstream game, they can hide their history.
Could this change have been presented better? Possibly. Could it be refined into a better change? Yes. Was this decision made with ill intent? I sincerely doubt it.
English
-
Just like Bungie, you are willing to toss away a community that's been here for more than a decade. And you call them greedy. I must applaud Bungie for making the first ever pay-to-post forum ever. In order to post, you must pay an entry fee. Maybe if you knew about the community that was there you'd be different. But of course, you will just take Activision's slap to the face.
-
Edited by Professor Oak: 10/13/2015 3:05:21 AM[quote]...the first ever pay-to-post forum ever.[/quote] someone obviously hasn't paid their $10
-
We shouldn't have to.
-
Like he said, getting the Destiny trial is free. It isn't a pay to participate sort of forum. You're misinformed.
-
There's no demo for Xbox One.
-
Uh... Pretty sure there is. I dunno.
-
Just checked 20 minutes ago. There isn't.
-
Well alrighty then.
-
My first ban was for posting "noob" in a reply. Remember those days? I do. Fade to "those days"....
-
I applaud you good sir. Only person not toxic enough to post something like this. But the orginal users of off topic will not be forgotten. For example our good freind longface who passed on the 23rd of August (scrambled his account)
-
tl;dr -blam!- you, Off Topic
-
Edited by jbx: 10/4/2015 8:03:15 AMIt doesn't pertain to just the flood.
-
[quote]Tough Love time. Take a break from the herd mentality for a few minutes and think about how much this actually affects you and your friends. Given that 99% of you have linked accounts, the answer is most likely "not very much." A few things I believe this is not: This is not an attempt to censor bad press about Destiny. As much as Bungie has the right to control what content appears on their website, they don't use it for active censorship. Some of the most damning criticism of their products is hosted on this very site, and available for the public to see. And let's be honest; the game has been out for more than a year; the only people who still care enough to complain about the game are people who are playing the game. This is not an attempt to extort money. As DeeJ said, less than 1% of us will be affected. They wouldn't take an action, let alone an action with the chance to stir up so much hate, to secure such a small number of sales. In addition, the notion is irrelevant, as a user can download the Destiny demo for [i]free[/i] with a [i]free[/i] XBL/PSN account, and create a Bungie.net account for [i]free[/i] to link it with. As long as you have an internet connection and a console that Bungie has developed for in the last 8 years, you can post here for [i]free.[/i] I believe what this really is is an honest attempt to clean up the forums. I have been here for a very long time, and I have seen many different moderation styles on this website. My first ban was for having an off-topic conversation in a thread (with the older layouts, this actually cluttered things up). There were about two dozen active forum moderators at the time. This was before we could embed pictures or videos, or even use (non-text) emoticons. As it stands, the game this website currently services is reported to have around 17,000,000 active users. If even 10% of them were active on the website at any given time, it would be way too much of a burden for 24 volunteer moderators to handle. Automated systems were put in place to handle this workload, but the general consensus is that they aren't getting the job done. It's extremely easy to create alt accounts, and moderators don't seem to have the resources to shut down prolonged attacks. Requiring linked accounts to post to the mains is a step against this. Granted, it can be maliciously bypassed quite easily, but it will discourage some, and improve the level of enforcement that can be delivered to those that do so (bans from the game itself). Most importantly, it gives the authorities more tools to track down the worst offenders. So who does this affect? A handful of aging NEETs who are drawn by nostalgia to Babby's First /b/ (#offtopic). I am sorry, but this website and this community does not owe them anything. In addition, they can retain their current level of access for free with minimal effort, it will ultimately just be slightly more tedious for them to evade bans. Such inhuman tragedy. Even if it weren't free, all it would mean is that they aren't allowed to post on the website of a company they haven't given any money to (barring store purchases) in the last 5 years. But wait, B.net actually is still catering to such people. They still have their accounts, and they can still post in private groups. You read that right; Bungie is letting people that don't even buy their games create their own private forums for free. So greedy. And even if these users are too cool to play a AAA mainstream game, they can hide their history. Could this change have been presented better? Possibly. Could it be refined into a better change? Yes. Was this decision made with ill intent? I sincerely doubt it.[/quote]
-
There must be a lot of alts if 17 billion people use this site
-
How many of those 99% actively post, or post outside of LFG? Who even cares about those numbers either way. It's the morals behind this decision. They are cementing the idea that we don't matter, and this site is only a place for destiny, even if they didn't want this policy to come across like that. Goodbye community, hello guardians(tm).
-
Less than 1%? Tell that too everyone from offtopic.
-
There are more than 1 sub forum. Additionally, whenever I've clicked on somebody's account recently to see if it's linked, a vast majority of them are. The only few I don't see are the handful of people that post political and religious threads every other hour.
-
Mhm yup 17 [b]billion [/b] accounts
-
Edited by TechnoKat: 10/1/2015 9:14:53 AMYeah, those are all good points and all. [spoiler]Situationally speaking. Which, by the way, those points only apply to an honest company, which NotBungie is not.[/spoiler] But what your missing is that this is [i]not[/i] Destiny.net. This forum has been around since [i][b]at least[/b][/i] the days of Halo 3, and the website tracked the stats of Halo 2. To suddenly decide to switch the rules of a website that was put together by another company all together (Bungie split in two, half stayed with Microsoft to become 343i, the other half left when Bungie's great and idiotic CEO fired anyone against Activision's "vision") in favor of a single game is far more than "cleaning up" the sites Alts. It's a message being sent to those of us who have been here since the start. That message is "Hey, get on the train, or get out, you're useless to us if you aren't feeding the cash cow." Another thing that you're missing is that NotBungie has routinely given examples of how little they regard the player base. Examples like: -More vault space? NERF ARS! -Need more vault space? NERF SUROS! -Need more vault space? Here, have [i]one more row[/i] and the ability to wear your helmet in the tower! And a music thing... And a prettier ball... -"We're making a game for [Xbox Players]. They should be grateful." _"It doesn't matter what we put in our DLC, you'll throw your money at the screen anyway." -TTK, where if you don't buy the new expansion, you don't need to be playing our game! -Oops, you weren't supposed to find that gun so soon, we're gonna have to nerf the Black Spindle. Let's not even go on about how Deej was allowed to ignore a forum members legitimate complaints about death threats being made against his familiar with his address and full Name. Fact is, that the people who honestly believe that this isn't a bad idea, are the ones who blindly play NotBungie's game.
-
Edited by jbx: 10/1/2015 8:36:21 AM[quote]Bungie is letting people that don't even buy their games create their own private forums for free. So greedy[/quote] Shoot, people can post in an unseen part of their website and still participate with the rest of the community, just like they used to, uninhibited. Oh wait.
-
[quote][quote]Bungie is letting people that don't even buy their games create their own private forums for free. So greedy[/quote] Shoot, people can post in an unseen part of their website and still participate with the rest of the community, just like they used to, uninhibited. Oh wait.[/quote]
-
Great post, Silent. But you need to fix that number.
-
I bet half of those users were to avoid bans
-
[quote]17,000,000,000 active users.[/quote] Well damn. Bungie hit it out of the park with destiny I guess. These numbers are through the roof!
-
17 billion users? That's like, almost enough to make me cupcakes.