{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
Edited by steg567:
10/1/2015 1:42:58 PM
411
3 jedi vs a fireteam of 3 guardians
3 jedi vs a fireteam in of 1 hunter, 1 titan, and 1 warlock who would win?
EDIT: the guardians supers are charged at the start of the fight but the jedi have access to all cannon force powers that jedi can use in combat.
English
#Destiny
-
Does shadowshot work on Jedi abilities? If so, guardians for the win.
-
The guardians would argue about who's class is better, while the jedi continued to slice them to bits.
-
Jango fett killed 6 jedi. I don't think guardians would have too much trouble. Op, you've gotta be specific which guardians vs which jedi?
-
Considering that the most powerful jedi A/ can sense danger long before it happens and B/ just use his mind to straight paralyze anything/anyone I don't see any victory whatsoever by any guardians
-
24 Replies3 Jedi would smoke the guardians. Hell Revan could beat more than 3 guardians without any help, put Yoda and Mace Windu into the mix itd be a guardian genocide.
-
You car kill that which can not die. Ready the resurrection protocols, and you would eventually kill the jedis with a spoon.
-
4 RepliesGuardians can self revive Jedi's cannot.
-
It depends on the Jedi imo
-
32 RepliesI love star wars, but this isn't even a fair fight. Guardians would destroy three jedi. Mainly because your average guardian is still more powerful than your average jedi. Now if we're talking a team of the likes of Yoda, Windu, and Vader, it would be a much closer match. I mean, Chancellor Palpatine kills those three jedi 'masters' in about two seconds when they try and detain him. My stormcaller is basically Papa Palp in the flesh. What do you thinks going to happen?
-
Ulic qel droma and Exar Kun could probably kill a fireteam by themselves. Hell, Galen Marek could probably kill a fireteam by himself. Unfortunately these characters aren't even canon anymore, so... oh well. K'kruhk could probably handle a fireteam as well. He's a powerhouse. [i]<3~~Shino Asada~~<3[/i]
-
1 ReplyGuardians because they have cheese
-
Watch the original Clone Wars cartoon from 2003. Jedis powerful there.
-
1 ReplyDepends on the Jedi really. Your average clone wars era jedi would be hosed, but say a Revan or an Obi-Wan are in the mix, its better odds.
-
I would have to say guardians. Now if it was a fire team of three guardians against a sith Lord and their apprentice then the guardians would lose.
-
1 ReplyGuardians because bungie would nerf the Jedi cause they were to OP
-
There is only one thing you need to know... Gjallahorn. [spoiler]Even after the nerf.[/spoiler]
-
1 ReplyThere are a few variables that we must consider. Jedi don't really like firearms. People who use the dark side of the force are the only ones really capable of dealing noticeable damage. Guardians have a HUGE range advantage, as well as the ability to revive each other. What weapons are available? Where is the set up of the fight? Are all six people fighting to the death, or a sparring/dojo like event where nobody dies or gets really hurt? What are the rules of engagement; Jedi, Guardian, mixed? Where are we, as in, what's the setting? Something neutral? Home field advantage? Are we in space? What's surrounding us? What's on the battlefield? Enemies? Junk? A halo style field where weapons are abundant? What is the definitive skill level of all parties? Are we talking about master Jedi versus legendary guardians? Novice on novice? Is this a handicap fight, where one of the two teams is a deliberate disadvantage? I need these questions answered before I can say for sure. If I set up my own parameters, I can't really say that people would like it, as I'm technically calling to two totally different fandoms here, and neither one of them would be happy with how I set this up.
-
Jedi can't do anything about lag
-
2 RepliesToo many variables to make a decision. From the level of talent actually fighting to what types of Jedi are we even talking about? Even if Sith are totally left out of the conversation, there are still the Gray Jedi who can wield aspects of the Light and Dark sides of the Force. So if you take 3 elite Grays vs say the Vanguard, Ikora, Zavala, and Cayde, it would be quite interesting, however I would have to give the advantage to the Jedi. Ionize is an ability that destroys machines, so that means Cayde would have to watch himself. Also, since people are saying that a Ghost can only be destroyed by Darkness, the Gray Jedi could destroy Ghosts which would make it so the Guardians cannot be revived. Also, people saying about Supers and whatnot seem to forget they need to charge up. Jedi would realize this and strike before the abilities could be used. Guardians are always encouraged to work as part of a fire team, whereas Jedi are can work as a team or solo. Taking that into account 3 extremely talented Jedi who work excellently on their own could backfire in a team aspect, however that isn't always the case. Still, personally I feel 3 Grays vs 3 Elite Guardians on neutral ground the Grays would take it hands down.
-
I'm gonna have to go with Jedi because I'm not sure what a "gaurdian" is...
-
1 ReplyEdited by Clark: 10/1/2015 10:52:54 AMIf it was Kit Fisto, Agen Kolar, and Saesee Tiin vs 3 guardians, the guardians would easily win. If you've seen Revenge of the Sith or are a hardcore star wars fan, you know exactly what I mean lmao Edit for the clueless: http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6pbNRfkgrio
-
Not gunna lie here, the Jedi have that whole business about being around after they're dead as something they can alter the material plane in, but guardians have revives and sparrows and dance functions. Guardians take the win on this one, and besides, a warlock is basically a Jedi with a cooler looking sword
-
6 RepliesHan shot first, case clsed
-
3 RepliesMy question is, why are they fighting?
-
Guardians depending on how far away they start fighting
-
2 RepliesShadowshot, Force stolen, game over.
