Nope its better

Doubt it - a lot. Bad recoil, slow RoF, relying on a 1:5 chance or being able to 2 shot someone (if you hit the head twice - and with that recoil, pretty low). Thorn already 2 shots people with a faster RoF and better stability. A Red Hand on the other hand, better stability, better recoil pattern, better RoF plus more rounds in the mag, quicker reload - do I need to say more?

Two shot kill. ... check mate