To be honest, I'd be surprised if the Enterprise could withstand a series of MACs even with their shielding, though, a photon torpedo would likely vaporize the Infinity before it had a chance to fire, assuming Kirk would do that rather than jumping to warp. Curiously, I think the UNSC would be able to track the Enterprise and pursue. I'd have to give it to whomever decided to go all-out first, but the Enterprise could definitely be quicker to the draw.
English
#Offtopic
-
5 RepliesThe Enterprise would be dust within a matter of moments. The Infinity and Enterprise simply aren't on the same level. The Infinity's point defenses would neutralise any number of torpedoes before they could get close to the hull. Plus, the Infinity has carrier capabilities. This is a heavy-weight fight. The Enterprise is simply not equipped or designed to engage such a powerful target.