Not really, that's what traditional GOTY editions are mostly. Get the base game and get all or a good chunk of the DLC for a discounted price then what was sold on launch and I doubt many people would have an issue if that was indeed the case since these are made to provide incentive to people who haven't bought the game and can get all of it for less. However the issue with this edition is it's the GOTY edition plus content exclusive only to this edition and that is what has people all up in a fuss about. For those who have been around since day one and bought in when it was first released, it feels unfair that we would have to buy the game all over again just to get that special digital content only available for those who buy in with this edition of the game. I don't recall a game from memory who did this sort of thing ever, it's the sort of thing you add when the game first came out not later when a year has already passed though if I am wrong please feel free to correct me. Even then still is a bit of a cheap tactic by Bungie and/or Activision to do this sort of thing.