In my opinion Heretic was a great remake of Midship in the Halo 3 Mythic Map pack. It was basically the exact same map with improved graphics and a few minor changes. With the new Reach videos here lately showing off the new Zealot map claiming it's a Midship remake what do you guys think about it? In my opinion it might be a fun map and the colors may be the same as the original Midship, but aside from that it doesn't really look that much the same especially with the new third floor. I'm not hating on the map or anything, I just don't think Bungie should consider it a remake when it really isn't even as close as Heretic.
-
Zealot is NOT a Midship remake, merely inspired by Midship. So by default, Heretic is the better remake. But I know I will like Zealot better than either because, personally, Heretic/Midship is WAY too small for any combat bigger than a 1 vs 1. Zealot has 3 levels, as well as a bigger interior in general.