Ok I'd say quite a few people have these two shaders but idk which one I should rock.
I'm leaning towards blacksmith because I don't like how sunsetting has the black helmet along with a black cloak.
As far as rarity, I've personally only seen two people in the tower with blacksmith and I've seen around six with sunsetting.
-
Everyone can eventually obtain Sunsetting. If you want to remain somewhat "legend" or unique I would equip Blacksmith as it is significantly less common, or at least will be in the next few weeks.