{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
Edited by Cremation:
10/28/2016 11:39:18 AM
631
Bungie, Your "Automatic" DDoS Detection must be BROKEN - People ranked top ten in the world show obvious wins by disconnecting opponents, several weeks in a row now.
Repost from r/dtg since they claim my wording here encourages witch hunting.
So a couple weeks ago I got legitimately DDoS'd out of a match on floating gardens. They kicked me and one other teammate out leaving it a 1v3.
Of course the last man in game reported them, and I sent a permalink through their Bungie.net system since I couldn't do it in game.
Today I go to check them out and what a surprise, they are STILL at it based off their previous matches. The worst part is, THEY ARE LITERALLY RANKED IN THE TOP 10 FOR ELO. They have been kicking SO many teams out for THREE WEEKS STRAIGHT that they are actually ranked in the top 10. This just makes me wonder how effective their report system is, their automatic detection is or a combination of both. A case like this should have swift action with the banhammer yet [b]this guy has kicked out HUNDREDS of players[/b]. The sad part is this is probably the type of guy that will simply make another account. I know Microsoft can block a console from access to Xbox live.
Quote from TWAB: We have several team members whose full-time jobs are to ensure the security of your Destiny experience. They tell us that in-game reports are the best way to send us data on malicious activity. [b]All in-game reports of cheating are monitored, and our security team closely examines all of the top reported offenders.[/b]
Well let's see here. [b]I just looked at this guys past 35 games, and he won them with over 100 players marked as "Deserters"[/b] Is this not a top reported offender? Is this not fitting the criteria for your automated systems? Those were just from the past 10 days. This guy's been at it for over a month.
I understand the elo system is not endorsed or used by Bungie, but you have team members whose full-time job is to handle these ingame reports, you would think they would have noticed this guy having polar opposite stats.
Perhaps it is time to look into more of the data that is being logged. The automated system isn't efficient. If you hit a threshold of wins with "deserters" it should be an automatic redflag for your full-time team to review that player.
I'm sorry if this is breaking a rule for witch hunting, but maybe a witch hunt is needed at this point. Just needed to get this rant out there.
English
#Destiny
-
I just got Dosed. I only played 80 Matches of Trials because i cant get into The Game
-
-
-
-
1 ReplyIt's very simple. If you cheat, you get permabanned. Why do they allow them a second chance? They will just do it again.
-
4 RepliesEver think that those said kids at the top are just drastically better than those players trying to win 5 games let alone 7 just to get some gear. Why stay and get shutout by a team that is wasting time on a card that is about to expire. I've personally left myself and had kids leave once they realize they're way out gunned.usually only takes a round or 2 to realize your neck deep in s $@t
-
Total bullshit that this topic is below some really trivial bullshit and has NO responses from Bung-me after almost a week.
-
To the top
-
1 ReplyThe problem with flagging people automatically for Victory by Deserters is what do you do with the people who rage quit? They'll be marked as deserters also, and no cheating was done; the losing players simply got frustrated and quit. Another thing is genuinely bad internet. There is nothing you can do about that except go through your ISP. The disconnect happens, the player gets marked as a Deserter. There have been many complaints about unjust banning due to genuinely bad internet. Automatic systems are good and definitely make life much, much easier, but entrusting the entire problem to an autonomous computer program is the recipe for disaster. Hence why they so strongly encourage the use of the in game system and the out of game form on their website
-
2 RepliesBump for later
-
Thanks Bungie.
-
-
-
1 ReplyStill awaiting a response from Cozmo, I think he is busy selling out somewhere.
-
Edited by KilllSwiitch: 10/31/2016 6:09:00 PMI don't play trials or pvp.. but i feel for pvp players.. BUNGIE DO SOMETHING ABOUT THE DDOS ATTACKS.. *SMH* REALLY!! DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT!
-
-
2 RepliesThis is why i wont ever go flawless
-
9 RepliesEdited by jnikoley: 10/31/2016 6:42:41 PMI've been keeping track of several accounts that are known DoSers. There are (were) 15 of them. The list would be much larger, but I'm not including the fireteam members they played with, just the actual DoSer. On Friday, 3 of those accounts were confirmed as restricted, meaning they cant play crucible for a minimum of a week, and can't play ToO for a minimum of a month. Today, 2 of the fifteen were banned permanently, meaning they can't play Destiny at all. Ever. Again (slow clap). These are the first full bans I've seen issued since vanilla. That said, the remaining 10 are still active, and playing ToO. Two of the ten are severe offenders with nearly every match played ending with a victory by disco. I'm aware that one of them offers lighthouse trips for money. Bungie, you're improving. You are finally issuing actual bans, and I applaud you for it. That said, you aren't doing enough. 2 bans out of 15 accounts is simply not enough. Edit: Since posting this, of the fifteen DoSers on my list, I added two more, so it's 17 now. Of the 17, 4 have now been permanently banned from Destiny. Two are restricted from crucible and ToO. That's still 11 remaining. Get busy Bungie. Edit: 19 now. No additional bans to report.
-
One of the reasons I'm leaving Destiny for Battlefield 1. I have yet to see a lag or DDOS on my end/ they have dedicated servers, take cheating seriously, and actually care for their players.
-
30 Replies"Our banhamner swings regularly" And misses consistently every time
-
-
10 RepliesThe lag is killing me. Faced a titan that tanked 3 rockets without taking damage. Hit a hunter with my shotgun for half damage and got killed by his with an identical roll at a farther distance. Warlocks with melee range the sive of the damn middle room A hunter that survived not one but 6 melees from a sunsinger including the initial 1HK melee. Titans that can 1HK melee max armor titans... This Playlist is everything wrong with pvp
-
Edited by Stari: 10/31/2016 12:39:34 PMI think that too many players play WI-FI!!!!!!!! When i'm on wi-fi, i get kicked many more times. This weekend i was doing Trials with 2 other friends. They have Wi-Fi, me not. At that time one of them was a fireteam leader. They got kicked and i didn't. Then i became a fireteam leader and we never got kicked. It was against 900 ELO players. I even won 2 rounds, playing 1 against 3. So if the fireteamleader has wi-fi, the chance you will get kicked is bigger.
-
-
last time I remember extreme crap like this happening, it was way back in the Halo 2 Days on Xbox LIVE... getting stuck on Zanzabar and as soon as the game began.... a nice blue screen telling you it's attempting to establish a connection again. You could hear everyone on your team, no dashboard features, no way to mute idiots who decided to scream and yell. When you came back, it was 0-50, you're laying dead in the water...being gang-t-bagged....corpse being pushed onto the windmill... or just laying there face down in the dirt. Ahh..... the good ole days. I would still prefer that over this.
-
