These are the 2 best halo games and I'm wondering which one the flood thinks is better.
Personally, I like halo 3 better. For multiplayer, reach wins by far, but the custom maps and campaign in 3 were better than the ones in reach.
-
Halo 3 had a superior multiplayer and campaign (still tons of plot holes) with great customs. Reach's campaign was weak and the multiplayer set Halo on a path to die (lolArmor Abilities and Loadouts). But it had superior custom games and forge. They didn't make it a better overall game then Halo 3 though. Halo 3 > Halo Reach