I gave it a 5/5. This is based on nothing other than the fact that I love playing this game. Does it have problems? Yes. But perfection is an unrealist yardstick to measure against. It is entirely reasonable that if you don't care for it, or you think there are things that must be improved, then you might give it a lower score. That's fair enough and you have to call it how you see it. For me though, any review score is irrelevant. The only fact that I care for is whether bungie/activision make enough to keep funding this game. Because I want keep playing it.