[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Kill 4 Funs Do you think you could be just a bit less retardedly critical and not imediately go, 'oh this is -blam!-' (not actucually quoted just trying to explain). I mean him and his friends tested it which means it must have some merit. -.-'[/quote]Retardedly critical? Really? I take the time to look carefully at a map, contemplate how gameplay will likely flow on the map, and have the courtesy to be honest about my opinion, and you say retardedly critical, and think I am saying 'oh this is -blam!-.' I said it isn't that great, I said why, and I said how I think it could be improved. Urk himself said that he didn't have a lot of experience making maps, and the mistakes I see are ones that are easy for a rookie mapmaker to make. I don't know about you, but I love getting feedback that goes straight to the biggest problem with a map, it makes it much easier to fix. Also, I pointed out that I have to base my feedback on descriptions and screenshots, so my impressions might be off. I am not some hypercritical guy who randomly tells other people how to make maps, I have a fair amount of experience building and testing maps in Halo 3 forge, so when I saw a few things that in my experience, would cause problems, I detailed them, and gave the solutions that I find to be the most effective. If Urk wants to ignore my ideas in favor of listening to experts at Bungie who know Reach much better, and are also better in general at map design because they have decades of experience, then that is perfectly fine, but I am going to help as much as I can by making my thoughts available. [Edited on 08.05.2010 6:40 AM PDT]