[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] WhaleFair [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] AR IS4 NUBS [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] WhaleFair [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] AR IS4 NUBS His posts didn't generate any form of discussion. That is why. They was too open and vague of a thread. It was a book with blank pages and a blank cover and yet he was the author.[/quote] People would reply to his posts and he would respond.... if thats not discussion, then idk what is.[/quote]That's not discussion. All his thread was for people to say ANYTHING and he'd draw it. There was no comparison debates or one-sided argument or even an idea. Just saying.[/quote] Ok there have been threads like that on The Flood, Its not against the rules.[/quote]I understand. But you're missing the point. There have always been some sort of a one-sidedness to a topic. Whether it be an idea or an opinion. It usually always ends with YOUR THOUGHTS? Or DISCUSSIONS. That leaves it open for people to chime in and put in their two-sense. But when you make a thread that is solely based on post count, not a good thread. (POST ANYTHING AND I SHALL DRAW IT) if he would have put in there some guidelines where as people can critique others, then maybe it would be ok. You get what i'm saying kinda? [Edited on 11.26.2012 3:09 PM PST]