I gotten two at the same time when we beat skolas and that my third and fourth! Seems everyone will get this!
-
My friends ran a 35 yesterday, all three of them got an elder cypher, and one of them got 2. I ran it later with the same guys and again all 3 of us got it, and I think two of us, me included, got two cypher drops. Kinda insane, maybe the patch broke something.