He mentions Vader has the edge on skills because of strength and speed... Voldemort doesn't need strength and he can disapperate quicker than Vader can jump.. don't see why he gave the edge to Vader on that one.. Vader gets the edge in round 2 because the guy said that it isn't in Voldemorts nature to disapperate when being attacked yet in OOTP he apperates and disapperates multiple times while fighting Dumbledore. Oh and then he goes on to say how he disapperates multiple times in the actual battle.. so what does he do? To assume he would just stand there ready to fight someone charging at him with a light saber is ludicrous. Their mind control is "basically the same with a slight edge to Voldemort"... I guess you had to give him one to make it look fair? He's messes up tho when talking about fight. Assuming his cruciartis curse hits Vader it would destroy any mechanical equipment it came in contact with. We see this multiple times throughout the books. If it's a direct hit in the chest it's Vaders respirator and he suffocates to death. This guy seemed knowledgeable about both subjects for the most part but you can tell he actually knows about the Star Wars universe and gives talking points about the HP world. I still give Voldemort the edge against Vader.