UDATE 7/16/15: [b]HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA[/b]
One of my previous posts. I couldn't find the thread, so here it is again. Note: TLW's TTK is actually [i]lower.[/i] Ridiculous.
[b][i][u]I have over 8,000 kills with the Thorn[/u][/i][/b]
Pre-post
*The Hawkmoon is actually way more balanced than TLW/Thorn. Its stability isn't great, and its TTKC isn't completely outrageous when compared to other guns.
*I am an avid user of both guns. I want them balanced because I dislike being forced to use them in order to counter them (why I use them).
*No, I don't think other guns should be buffed to match these (if you were going to propose this, that just proves how out of line these guns are) because that would be 20x harder than simply balancing these 2 weapons.
(TTK = time to kill)
(TTKC = time to kill crit)
(ADS = aim down sights)
TLW TTKC: .56
Thorn TTKC: .36 (this is how long it takes to land two head shots. The number .36 does not account for the burn damage after the two head shots are landed.)
[url=https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/tTMPEAOhYplzPIA4B07pBhQ/htmlview]Spread sheet[/url]
First of all, if you're one of the few people that are actually willing to take this thread seriously, take a look at that spread sheet and pay attention to the "Time To Kill Crit" column. The hand cannon class, specifically exotic hand cannons, are vastly superior to literally every other weapon except for Red Death and Vex Mythoclast. They're two tenths of a second better than every other primary, and one tenth of a second better than the Mytho & Red Death. This means that if two players, one with TLW and one with RD, are fighting head to head, and both players are using the guns to their full potential, TLW will win 100% of the time. And no, saying "well stay out of close range to avoid TLW" isn't a valid option because of the current maps.
The Last Word (TLW)
I'll start with TLW. First of all, TLW's exotic perk is broken. It's supposed to deal bonus damage when hip fired, right? Well, currently it's bugged and exploitable. Ever notice how sometimes you'll ADS with it and gain bonus damage? That's the bugged part. Sometimes it randomly decides to give you extra damage. However there's currently an exploit (or bug or whatever you want to call it. Idc about the technicality) that allows you to gain the bonus damage while ADS'd 100% of the time. And it's really easy! All you have to do is press the right trigger before you press the left trigger. Keep both pressed down and bam. 111 head shots for days (I don't mind giving this info out because the more people that do it/know it, the faster it gets patched!). This means that even at medium range TLW can achieve its .56 TTKC fairly consistently. This is specially broken for skirmish where TLW shines, even without abusing its broken perk.
Fix: The perk should obviously be fixed. I think we can all agree on that, even if you don't think exotic HCs are OP. The RoF also need to be lowered. I'm not sure how much it needs lowering, but I'll throw out a number and say 2%, giving other weapons a chance against this silly weapon.
Thorn
Thorn's TTK is a bit confusing. The chart says .36, but that isn't its true TTK if we're being technical. That time (.36) is how fast you can land two head shots, which with the Thorn's stability, isn't too hard for competent players. Of course the enemy isn't immediately dead after two head shots, they still have to burn (so they're basically zombies after two head shots). I accept the number .36 as Thorn's true TTKC because most players blink away to cover after doming someone twice. .36 is MILES above ALL other weapons. That number is better than most LMGs! And the "stay out of close quarters" is an even less valid solution to countering this gun because of its range.
If you actually read until this point then put "Read." before your response so I can take you seriously. Thanks.
Fix: Remove the perfect balance perk from Thorn's tree and reduce its RoF by around 5%.
TL;DR: No. Read the post. I'll be ignoring "git gud" type posts unless I need bumps.
"I can do good without them, so they aren't OP."
Good job! So can I. But you and I would undoubtedly do better with them.
I have a 2.35 KD overall. I have over a 4 KD in trials. I'm approaching 30 days played. As I previously stated, I have over 8,000 Thorn kills. I participate in sweaties against top players regularly. I say this not to brag, but to add credibility to myself as these stats are the only way to judge me without playing me.
English
#Destiny
-
1 AntwortenPlease, stop these stupid ass posts!!!
-
1 AntwortenLast Word isn't bad at all not like the thorns damage over time
-
1 AntwortenIf thorn is op in pvp then fatebringer is op in pve. Use the good weapon at the right time.
-
10 AntwortenThey are meant to be exotics that means they are meant to be powerful and thorn is supposed to be one of the best guns in the game so must stand out amongst the rest
-
3 AntwortenThe last word is ridiculously broken imo
-
I definitely agree and have thrown out the rof nerf before on other forum posts. I think it should have a timurs lash rof St this point. Because having the same rof as last word is so ridiculous. In addition I hope they soon fix the last word issue with the critical bug.
-
2 AntwortenHush little baby don't you cry, Thorn's gonna sing you a lullaby. Two straight shots to your head, to make sure you are dead. And if that good ol' Thorn don't kill, Damage Over Time sure will. Fusions and shotguns don't you fret, post mortem kills is what we'll get. And if you're still alive, beware. There's plenty more Thorns in the Garden there.
-
I'm pretty bad at PVP but I don't have any problem with both of the guns. I survived Thorn burning effect times and got killed a lot with many different guns.
-
Absolutely
-
[b]DUCK & COVER![/b]
-
2 Antworten
-
Just saying if you can still edit it would probably be good to post a few TTKs from some other popular guns to show the differences. Red death, bad juju, vex, and some legendary ones too.
-
Bearbeitet von ISpeakLOGIC: 6/6/2015 5:47:21 PM
-
2 Antworten
-
I agree the last word bug should be fixed but if you refuse the rate of fire or impact on these guns or hand cannons generally why would anyone use them. If you bring the ttk in line with pulse and auto rifles then their larger magazine size and better reload speeds make them op. Any nerf would therefore have to be tiny. Unless you make every gun the same then there will always be advantages to certain guns in certain situations. I tend to use the vex more now even though the ttk is slower because of the magazine size and xcellent stability.
-
if thorn and tlw are op, then i wonder how the vex mythoclast and felwinter's lie should be called... one 3 shots at hip fire, can be faster than thorn and has a bigger clip, the other is the same as a fusion rifle with no charging time but those don't seem to bother you
-
If you use perfect balance on Thorn, you're doing it wrong lol
-
1 AntwortenWhy don't you just remove the burn from thorn after you kill the user.
-
You on xbox? Or did u forget that hawkmoon destroys both them guns?
-
I have both guns but they shouldn't nerf them. Honestly. Think of it this way: Everyone would only use the vex then people would complain about nerfing it Those are 2 less guns to care about Also, PVp changes are coming, don't worry There would be complaints about buffing them
-
Bearbeitet von cows: 5/9/2015 5:01:22 PMAgreed. Anybody who's actually good at pvp and had experience with both guns along with many others should see they need tweaking. They just need smaller mags. Thorn should be reverted and tlw should have 6 rounds. They're way too forgiving when they miss, and that's the only problem aside from the tlw bug/hidden perk.
-
2 AntwortenWho uses perfect balance on thorn. All about send it
-
Bearbeitet von ISpeakLOGIC: 5/9/2015 11:45:59 PM
-
Just fix the perk on the last word so you can only two shot when hip firing thorn idk how to fix it leave that to bungie
-
Don't complain about those weapons when EVERY shotgun has a potential TTK at 0.01. It's not like Felwinter's has a range of TLW anyway. Don't complain about Thorn when the bounty of it is the reason half of your teammates you play with have a 0.07 KD because of the Void Challenge. Don't complain about weapons in PvP when a game is more PvE focused than PvP.
-
2 AntwortenNo more nerfing the damn weapons! Enough is enough! I don't care which weapon it is because even if they nerfed the hell outta thorn/TLW then you would just complain about vex or felwinters lie or whatever gun ends up being the best because the 'best' ones just got nerfed down to not be the best anymore. There will always be that 'one gun' that outperforms slightly. Just deal with it and adapt your gameplay accordingly.