With that logic a professional athlete should never listen to a coach that has never played professionally. Someone could have an excellent grasp of the game and not have the physical attributes required to be successful in pvp i.e reflexes, eyesight, spatial awareness etc.

[quote]If A is better than B in something, A's opinion is more valuable High tier players have better understanding of the crucible and they are more dedicated to it, what they say should be precious[/quote] Not always the case but it usually is. The only case I see against it is class balance but that’s because everyone prefers their main.

By the same logic streamers' opinion about PvE must be much more valuable than the average player. I guess you'll agree to that.

Ok, but most of them know the game anyway About kd players, you have no doubt about their lack of skill

Agreed. I'm sure I'd have an amazing kill/death ratio too if I went around with my friends in a 6-stack, 4-stack etc. and/or set my VPN to a corner of the globe with virtually no players so I could get matched with my friends for easy 100+ match win streaks... but that would not be indicative of my skill. Similarly, I'm sure I'd have an amazing kill/death ratio if I built a hardware lag switch or used Net Limiter 4 to lag out my opponents whenever I saw a red dot on my radar... but it also would not be indicative of my skill level in anything except network manipulation skill. ;P I play solo in large part because I want to know how well I do on my own, and to improve my skills against similarly-skilled players, and no matter if I hate a game type like Control, I will _always_ play objective and at least try to win the match objectives, rather than just going for kills. But I'd prefer to just go for kills, which is why I would prefer to just play Clash all the time, but Bungie seem to not want to make Clash a base, default game type for some inexplicable reason, even though that is the default on just about any other PvP FPS. :P

Nope, before talking about something you need to know it If your nephew played destiny he wouldn't claim anything anyway because he isn't dedicated as you said In general, better players play more than bad players

Nah. It has nothing to with ego. If a person is better at the game the know about it more and would be good for it.

This argument would work if not for the fact that the best PvP players are also usually the people who have played PvP the most (I'm talking about Destiny specifically here.) Yes, someone who is just generally good at PvP in games, but is playing Destiny for the first time, has an opinion that arguably has less merit than the opinion of an average PvP player who has sunk hundreds of hours into Destiny's PvP specifically. But, again, most of Destiny's top PvP players have both skill [i]and[/i] experience. I can almost guarantee most of them were average players once too. They became good because they put in the time to improve.

Um pretty sure history shows the opposite minority groups are always very vulnerable without mainstream support

[quote]Elderly people tend to screw things up more than middle aged. I can sink hours into something, and have an average score, and still have a more valid opinion than the "good" person with less. For example, where I work. I have been here for 15 years, basic degree. Some new guy with a masters in biology comes in thinking he knows everything. The dumbass gets bit because he doesn't know our animals. [/quote] I used to work in a lab where some of our seasoned mid-leveled employees had to supervise phd candidates and post-docs. It was fun to watch at times.

LMFAOOOOOOOOOOO

[quote]That's why when you need a surgery you ask for a 1 year experienced doctor and not for a 30 years experienced one[/quote] Everyone starts out with >1 year of experience. That’s… how years work… sure I might prefer having someone with more experience, but it doesn’t really matter to me. If in that one year the doctor performed the same surgery with a 100% success rate, I have no reason to assume that my surgery will not also be successful. [quote]That's why when you need help on work you'll ask to your good colleague and not the bad one[/quote] If my “bad” colleague had trouble dealing with that specific issue or question, I might go to them to see where they went wrong, figure out how I might do things differently. Failure is an excellent tool for future success. [quote]Tomorrow i'll go to CERN and claim my opinion should matter more than the engineers there then[/quote] As a consumer, your opinion on design can and in some situations should be taken into consideration. Not in this situation since the rude description you give would probably have you thrown out of the building, but engineers should be open to public opinion when designing something for public use. Obviously your opinion does not matter “more” since you have no actual power there. If you play Destiny, regardless of if you are good or bad at PvP, you would be treated the same way. Thrown out of the building because regardless of your skill in the Crucible, you don’t work for Bungie, and have no power over the way Destiny functions.

Ofc, but more experience is more valuable Usually the best players have more time invested than the bad ones And honestly if someone is bad after a long time, his/her understanding of the game isn't good