What's the first game that at the time you considered basically "perfect"? Name the game, what system it was on, and any commentary around your thoughts. Mine was Super Mario Bros. 3 for the original NES. EDIT: great suggestions everyone. There are definitely a few on here I never got to play that I'll have to go back and try to get to! EDIT 2: looking like Halo 3 and Star Wars Battlefront II are the leaders (halo is ahead if you consider all Halo as a franchise). One not mentioned, but all these great ideas got me to thinking about was Dark Cloud or Rogue Galaxy for ps2. Fantastic rpgs if you've never played them