That people think he is a moron or a douchebag doesn't really matter. That people think he regurgitates what the community in general thinks doesn't matter. He is spot on with this review. The points he brings up are all valid and he does list good and great aspects of the game. The only thing I found myself dissagreing on was how good the multiplayer is. It's good, but no where near as good as he said. If he puts what the general population of the game is thinking into a review, is it not a good tool for developers to use to find ways to improve customer satisfaction? Does it not give people buying it a good idea of what others have experiecned rather than just what one critic thinks? Not really a fan of his delivery or anything, but apparently a lot are, so whatever works for him.