I don't personally use the word "sellout", but I have had instances where bands I like move in a different direction and lose me. Metallica is a great example, because while it is common for people to knock them for pursuing mainstream success starting with the Black Album, I just personally didn't like the direction they were heading in (although I wouldn't say the Black Album and all post 80s Metallica is bad by any stretch). This is not because it was more popular, and not because they were experimenting; it is because they deviated from what they were in the beginning, and not in a good way.
The thing is, a band is always making a gamble when trying to change their sound; their hardcore fans might like the result, and they might pick up new fans, but they could also end up doing the opposite of both. I like some bands that evolved over time (Deftones, for instance), and others have disappointed me when they tried to change (such as Incubus).
To sum it up, change is good, but not inherently, and there's a huge layer of subjectivity thrown in. As for me, popularity just isn't even a factor; I either like it or I don't.
English
-
wasn't it Metallica who said that they were now only making new material for the money? when you stop making music for the sake of the music, that's when you become a 'sellout' in my opinion; it doesn't matter how 'mainstream' you get or anything else.
-
I don't know if any member of Metallica has ever said that, but to me it was obvious that they changed in order to appeal to more people. I am still a little hard-pressed to call any musician a sellout, because I couldn't imagine that they'd do what they do if they didn't love music to some degree. I can understand why some feel bitter when bands they love stoop downward into a monetary mindset, but I still have to say that I let the quality of the music as I perceive it carry the most weight.
-
at the end of the day, if the music's good the music's good, no matter the motive behind it. [url=http://musicmp3.ru/news_metallica-do-tours-only-for-money.html]but yeah they apparently only tour for the money[/url]
-
Most bands tour for the money, it's not all we love our fans...
-
Amen, and that is troubling to hear from Kirk. On top of that, I'm not too thrilled with his admission that the next album will be more akin to the Black Album.