Ther e is absolutely zero reason they can't split the two. World of Warcraft did this flawlessly. You're worthless raiding in PvP gear, and you're worthless doing PvP in PvE gear. No reason the crucible and other PvP events can't have specific armor with specific PvP perks and vice versa. I don't understand why they don't do this. It fixes almost everything because it frees them up to focus on both sides and not balance one to break another.